Search This Blog

Thursday, June 11, 2015

Use of "Fee-Only" Inappropriately or Any Use of "Fee-Based" Can Violate Federal/State Laws


A reader asks: “Can a series 7/66 rep who works for a regional dually registered (broker-dealer and RIA) firm claim to be fee-only, fee-based, and commission-based at the same time?”

Short Answer: No. The terms “fee-only,” “fee-and-commission” and “commission-and-fee” should be used properly. If a person claiming to be “fee-only” or the person’s firm receives material third-party compensation (in the form of commissions, 12b-1 fees, payment for shelf space, etc.), then the use of the term "fee-only" likely violates one or more federal or state securities laws or other consumer protection laws. Additionally, the term “fee-based” should never be utilized to describe an advisor, as it is inherently misleading.

Background

The term “fee-based” apparently arose to describe “fee-based brokerage accounts” – which were permitted for nearly a decade by the SEC under the ill-fated “Merrill Lynch Rule.” The SEC’s rule was overturned in 2007 by the D.C. U.S. Court of Appeals in Financial Planning Ass’n v. SEC, as violative of the “no special compensation” requirement for brokers to be exempt from registration under the Advisers Act.

Following that 2007 decision time was permitted for brokers to change the fee-based accounts to either commission-based brokerage accounts or to investment advisory accounts. Many registered representatives (RRs) of broker-dealer firms converted the accounts to investment advisory accounts, and many of these representatives secured their Series 66 (or 65) licenses in order to be qualified to be an “investment adviser representative” (IAR).

Unfortunately, during this time the term “fee-based” became more widely used to describe the dual registrant (RR/IAR), rather than the account. Some speculate that this was in response to the marketing success fee-only advisors possessed. In particular, hundreds of thousands of consumer inquiries proceed each year through the find-an-advisor web site hosted by the National Association of Personal Financial Advisors (www.NAPFA.org), resulting in many referrals of consumers to its 2,500 or so fee-only members.

The term “fee-only” was apparently coined by NAPFA many, many years ago. Currently NAPFA’s definition of “fee-only” states: “NAPFA defines a Fee-Only financial advisor as one who is compensated solely by the client with neither the advisor nor any related party receiving compensation that is contingent on the purchase or sale of a financial product. Neither Members nor Affiliates may receive commissions, rebates, awards, finder’s fees, bonuses or other forms of compensation from others as a result of a client’s implementation of the individual’s planning recommendations. ‘Fee-offset’ arrangements, 12b-1 fees, insurance rebates or renewals and wrap fee arrangements that are transaction based are examples of compensation arrangements that do not meet the NAPFA definition of Fee-Only practice.”

In contrast, the Certified Financial Planner Board of Standards, Inc. defines a fee-only certificant (i.e., Certified Financial Planner™) as follows: “A certificant may describe his or her practice as ‘fee-only’ if, and only if, all of the certificant’s compensation from all of his or her client work comes exclusively from the clients in the form of fixed, flat, hourly, percentage or performance-based fees.” It should be noted that the CFP Board’s application of this definition takes into account the specific facts and circumstances of the certificant.

While the major online dictionaries don’t apparently yet provide a definition for “fee-only,” “The Free Dictionary by Harlex” defines “fee-only compensation” as “Payment to a financial adviser of a set hourly rate, or an agreed-upon percentage of assets under management, for a financial plan. Under this arrangement, the adviser receives no commissions on any transactions to implement the plan.”

Analysis

What is the perception of consumers? This is important, because a commonly held understanding by consumers could establish a definition of the term that could result in a securities law violation if the term was misused. However, it is unclear, in my mind, whether consumers would even recognize the “fee-only” term and know what it means, the majority of the time.

But some consumers, whether through readings about fee-only advisors (consumer media writers often caution their readers to seek out “fee-only advisors”) or just through commonly accepted meanings of “fee” and “only” might achieve a understanding of the term “fee-only” in alignment with the definitions provided by either NAPFA or the CFP Board, or both.

(Of course, we must ask how many consumers can articulate the difference between a stock, a mutual fund, and a bond. A low level of financial literacy among consumers excuses neither deceit nor fraud.)

Consumer understanding is not the sole test of the proper use of a term. A commonly held use of the term “fee-only” within the securities industry itself, with dissemination of the term to consumers through marketing and promotional efforts, could also provide the foundational meaning of the term. Any subsequent misuse of the term could then be the foundation for a securities law violation.

Michael Kitces, a widely-respected financial planning industry commentator, summarized past controversies over the term “fee-only” in his recent Nerd’s Eye View blog post (found online at https://www.kitces.com/blog/9-out-of-top-10-cnbc-fee-only-advisory-firms-not-actually-fee-only-according-to-cfp-board-compensation-disclosure-rules/):

Nonetheless, the fact that the companies acknowledged the existence of the commissions and disclose them in the Form ADV means, almost by definition, these firms are not fee-only! In fact, holding out as a "fee-only" advisor while the advisor (or his/her parent firm) has a related entity that is an insurance agent is the exact issue that brought about the complaint with the CFP Board against Jeff and Kim Camarda, and the subsequent Camarda vs CFP Board lawsuit that has ensued. Similarly, an advisor holding out as being "fee-only" while working for a company with a related entity that generates commissions was what led to the resignation and subsequent public admonition of former CFP Board chair Alan Goldfarb. And after an article on this blog pointed out that under the related-party rules, any advisor working for a broker-dealer is in violation of the "fee-only" rules simply by the fact that they work there, the CFP Board had to reset the compensation disclosures on its own website after a follow-up story in Financial Planning magazine revealed hundreds were in violation of the "fee-only" disclosure rules.

As Michael Kitces’ blog also pointed out, the term “fee-only” continues to be a point of controversy and continues to snag advisors and firms, sometimes through no fault of their own. As James Dornbrook reported in the Kansas City Business Journal on June 10, 2015:

Leawood-based Creative Planning was recently named as the nation's No. 1 fee-only wealth management firm by CNBC for the second year in a row. Creative Planning didn't apply for the award. It was thrust upon the firm unknowingly, and it ended up in the national media.

Soon after CNBC announced its list, Michael Kitces, a well-known commentator and editor of the Journal of Financial Planning, skewered it by questioning whether nine of the 10 firms recognized truly have a fee-only structure. His criticism included Creative Planning, which Kitces said refers clients to insurance affiliates the firm owns, so it shares in those insurance commissions.

Creative Planning founder Peter Mallouk said that when it comes to making any types of investments, his firm is certainly impartial and fee-only, focused entirely on getting clients into the best investments that fit their risk profile and goals.

That said, Creative Planning does have affiliates that offer insurance coverage. However, most of the coverage is group coverage, such as health insurance and property and casualty insurance for businesses. The company does offer insurance policies for individuals, such as term life, health, home and auto, but the offerings do not include any insurance that could be considered an investment vehicle, such as variable life or variable annuities.

The CNBC list required that all firms be fee-only when it comes to investments. It also required that the firms on its list be able to advise on insurance because it wanted to recognize firms that offered a full suite of wealth management services. Creative Planning offers money management, financial advice, legal and tax services, and insurance. So it's got the full package and serves clients well in each area, which is why it got recognized.

Should Creative Planning and similar firms be considered a pure "fee-only" firm when only a small part of their business makes commissions on clients for insurance sales? CNBC thinks so …

It should be noted that in a 2007 state securities administrator proceeding involving an investment adviser representative who also sold insurance products, the use of the term “fee-only” was found to be misleading and violative of state securities anti-fraud laws. See IN THE MATTER OF: MICHAEL G. GRIMES; and FINANCIAL SOLUTIONS & ASSOCIATES, INC., Case No. AP-07-04 (State of Missouri, Office of the Secretary of State) (available at http://www.sos.mo.gov/securities/orders/AP-07-04a.asp). The State Securities Administrator’s sanctions were upheld on appeal to the Missouri Court of Appeals (Financial Solutions and Associates v. Carnahan (Case No. WD71332 (July 20, 2010). I provide this extended excerpt from the appellate decision:

At the time of the investigation, Grimes [licensed as an insurance agent, not as an investment adviser representative] was acting as a solicitor for Barrington and had his own business, FSI. Grimes was licensed to sell life insurance, variable contracts, accident, and health insurance coverage.   Barrington was a federally covered investment adviser. Between March 31, 2005, and June 30, 2006, Grimes received over $150,000 in compensation from Barrington. FSI's website, maintained by Grimes, contained a section called “Fee-Only Planner.” That section clearly stated:

 “[FSI] is a fee-only planning firm committed to assisting client[s] to reach their financial goals.   Fee only planners, like us, are compensated solely by fees paid by their clients and do not accept commissions or compensation from any other source.”

“The main difference between a Stockbroker and us is that they make a living by charging their clients commissions.”

“We do not earn any money from commissions, trailers, or markups.”

At the hearing before the Commissioner, Janet Ellingson, an account manager for LiveOffice, who Grimes used to build and house his website, testified that when Grimes gave the information for his initial questionnaire, he stated that he was a fee-only investment advisor. Grimes testified that it was his responsibility, knowing what licenses they had, to build the site and select the proper pages that would equal the services they were licensed to offer.   Grimes also admitted that he was a solicitor for Barrington at the same time he maintained his website and would receive 60% of the management fee that Barrington received when they managed the clients Grimes brought to them.

After a review of the record on appeal, particularly the evidence presented regarding the website and the commissions the Appellants received at the same time the website proclaimed they were “fee-only,” we conclude the Commission's finding is supported by competent and substantial evidence.

Moreover, to the extent Grimes contends that the Commissioner erred in finding the statements constitute fraud or deceit under § 409.5-502(a), that argument also fails … “[i]t is recognized in Missouri, as well as generally, that the primary purpose of legislation similar to that of the Missouri Uniform Securities Act is that of protecting the buyers of securities.” Garbo v. Hilleary Franchise Sys., Inc., 479 S.W.2d 491, 499 (Mo.App.E.D.1972) (internal quotation and asterisks omitted). To fulfill that purpose, we “embod[y] a flexible rather than a static principle, one that is capable of adaptation to meet the countless and variable schemes devised by those who seek the use of the money of others on the promise of profits.”Id. (internal quotation omitted). As noted supra, under § 409.5-502(a):

It is unlawful for a person that advises others for compensation, either directly or indirectly or through publications or writings, as to the value of securities or the advisability of investing in, purchasing, or selling securities or that, for compensation and as part of a regular business, issues or promulgates analyses or reports relating to securities:  (1) To employ a device, scheme, or artifice to defraud another person;  or (2) To engage in an act, practice, or course of business that operates or would operate as a fraud or deceit upon another person.

The Appellants contend that fraud and deceit under the Missouri Securities Act require the making of a false or misleading statement of material fact, or the failure to disclose a material fact necessary to avoid making another statement not misleading. They contend that the statements from FSI's website do not meet this definition. Fraud and deceit are not defined in the Missouri Securities Act. However, the terms “ ‘[f]raud,” “deceit,” and “defraud” are not limited to common law deceit.” § 409.1-102(9).

When interpreting the meaning of words used in the Missouri Securities Act, we look to other states' interpretations of their securities law as well as federal interpretations. Moses, 186 S.W.3d at 904 (“Missouri courts have often looked to cases decided by courts from other jurisdictions to aid in comprehending the definitional limitations of the Act, particularly when the language of the federal and state securities statutes involved is nearly identical.”);  State v. Dumke, 901 S.W.2d 100, 102 (Mo.App.W.D.1995) (“[W]hen construing uniform acts, it must be remembered that the fundamental purpose of a uniform law is to eliminate uncertainty and provide plain and certain the controlling rules of law. It is fitting, therefore, to turn to our sister jurisdictions and examine their solutions to the problem.” (Internal citation and quotation omitted)).

Similar to federal securities legislation, Missouri securities legislation makes it unlawful for persons to engage in practices or a course of business that “operates or would operate as fraud or deceit.” § 409.5-502(a) (emphasis added);  cf.  17 C.F.R. § 240.10b-5(c). This language “quite plainly focuses upon the effect of particular conduct on members of the investing public, rather than upon the culpability of the person responsible.” Aaron v. Sec. & Exch. Comm'n, 446 U.S. 680, 697, 100 S.Ct. 1945, 1955, 64 L.Ed.2d 611 (1980). This same approach has been followed in other states, as these states have also relied on the Aaron decision. See, e.g., Secretary of State v. Tretiak, 22 P.3d 1134, 1141 (Nev.2001).

Moreover, when a definition is not present in the statute, “the plain and ordinary meaning is derived from the dictionary.” Cox v. Dir. Of Revenue, 98 S.W.3d 548, 550 (Mo. banc 2003).  “Fraud” is defined as “[a] knowing misrepresentation of the truth or concealment of a material fact to induce another to act to his or her detriment.” Black's Law Dictionary 731 (9 th ed.2009). “Deceit” is defined as “[t]he act of intentionally giving a false impression.” Id. at 465. It is also defined as “[a] false statement of fact made by a person knowingly or recklessly with the intent that someone else will act upon it.” Id. The evidence presented in the record on appeal demonstrates that the FSI website's language meets these definitions.

The Commissioner did not err in determining that Grimes's statements on the FSI website constituted fraud or deceit under the Missouri Securities Act. The Commissioner's decision is in line with other state and federal decisions and meets the definitions given to these terms. We attempt to construe the Missouri Securities Act in a manner that is consistent with the Commissioner's interpretation, Moses, 186 S.W.3d at 899, and we do not find that the Commissioner's interpretation was unreasonable or arbitrary.   Point denied.

The Commissioner's decision finding that Appellants engaged in an act, practice, or course of business that operated as fraud or deceit upon persons under § 409.5-502(a) is affirmed.

As seen, representations regarding “fee-only” by a person who does not meet the generally accepted definition of that term (whether such definition is promulgated by industry organizations or has achieved more widespread use in the public jargon) is likely to constitute “fraud” or “deceit” under federal and state securities laws.

Conclusions.

Permit me to offer my own opinion as to the likelihood of organizational rules or securities / insurance law violations. Of course, each situation is fact-specific; nevertheless, some general legal conclusions can be offered.

If a Certified Financial Planner™ or her/his firm receives any commission-based compensation, 12b-1 fees, or other material third-party compensation, and the certificant uses the term “fee-only” (either on the CFP Board’s find-an-advisor web site, or in any other marketing or promotional materials, or verbally) to describe either: (1) the certificant; (2) the nature of the certificant’s practice; or (3) the nature of her or his firm, then the certificant has probably violated the CFP Board’s rules. If you, the reader, spot such occurring, I would urge you to first contact the certificant, suggest that she or he review the CFP Board’s rules, and permit a reasonable time for corrective action to occur. The appropriate characterization of the practice and/or the advisor and/or the firm should be either “fee-and-commission” or “commission-and-fee” (depending upon which predominates, as a percentage of total revenue). If corrective action by the certificant or the certificant’s firm does not occur, I would urge the reader to file a written complaint with the CFP Board about the certificant.

Regardless of whether the dual registrant (RR/IAR), or perhaps an IAR with an insurance license, possesses status as a CFP®, another issue is whether fraud is occurring under the federal or state securities laws, or common law fraud occurs under state common law. Given the long-standing use of the term “fee-only” within the industry, by both NAPFA and the CFP Board, and given that a significant minority of consumers would likely understand the term “fee-only” as connoting arrangements other than third-party compensation, I would opine that the use of the term “fee-only” would be fraudulent to describe the individual Series 65/66 license holder if that license holder received third-party compensation (such as commissions, 12b-1 fees, etc.).

If the advisor is a registered representative, then FINRA Rule 2210(d)(1)(B) prohibits a firm from making any false, exaggerated, unwarranted or misleading statement or claim in any communication, and prohibits the publication, circulation or distribution of any communication that the firm knows or has reason to know contains any untrue statement of a material fact or is otherwise false or misleading. I would opine that the inappropriate use of the term “fee-only” by a registered representative who also receives commissions or other material third-party compensation, whether from sales of securities or insurance products, is not “fee-only” and that any use of the term “fee-only” would likely violate of FINRA Rule 2210(d)(1)(B). Again, I would urge the reader to contact the registered representative and or her/his firm, and seek that they undertake corrective action within a reasonable period of time. If appropriate action is not appropriately undertaken, I would urge the reader to file a written complaint with FINRA.

If the advisor is not a registered representative, but holds as Series 65/66 license and an insurance licenses, and if the advisor inappropriately use of the term “fee-only” due to receipt of commissions or other material third-party compensation from insurance products, whether through the same firm or through an affiliated insurance firm or even a non-affiliated insurance agency, then I would opine that the advisor is again not “fee-only.” I would note that any use of the term “fee-only” would likely be considered an “advertisement” (any communication addressed to more than one person that offers any investment advisory service with regard to securities) under “the Advertising Rule” — Rule 206(4)-1). Note that an advertisement could include both a written publication (such as a website, newsletter or marketing brochure) as well as oral communications. Under the Advisers Act, advertising must not be false or misleading and must not contain any untrue statement of a material fact. Regardless of whether an “advertisement” exists, all statements made to advisory clients and prospective clients, is subject to the general prohibition on fraud (Section 206 as well as other anti-fraud provisions under the federal securities laws). Again, I would opine that it is likely that a Sect. 206 violation has taken place. I would urge the reader to contact the investment adviser representative and or her/his firm, and seek that they undertake corrective action within a reasonable period of time. If appropriate action is not appropriately undertaken, I would urge the reader to file a written complaint with either the SEC (if the advisor’s firm is registered with the SEC) or with the home state of the advisor’s firm (if the advisor’s firm is not “SEC-registered”).

If the advisor is only an insurance agent, and advertises as a “fee-only” financial or investment advisor, then violations of the anti-fraud provisions of state insurance laws, and/or state consumer laws against unfair or deceptive practices, may have occurred. While this will depend upon that state’s laws, again I would urge the reader to seek corrective action by contacting the insurance agent first, then if correction action is not timely undertaken then filing an appropriate report with either the state insurance commissioner’s office, or the state trade commission, or both.

I believe the term "fee-based" to describe an advisor is intentionally misleading, when utilized. Where both fee revenue (AUM, fixed fees, hourly fees) or commissions (or other third-party compensation) is received, an advisor is properly characterized as either "fee-and-commission-based" or "commission-and-fee-based," depending upon where the majority of the revenue of the advisor is derived. The omission of "and-commission" in either instance, an attempt to obfuscate and gain the consumer's trust inappropriately, and hence in my view constitutes deceit under federal and state securities laws.

These are my conclusions only. Again, these conclusions are based upon the general understanding of the law, and varying sets of facts might lead, in particular cases, to different results. Additionally, while one reported decision exists as to the use of the term “fee-only,” other decisions may exist, and/or new cases may arise, which result in different decisions. Nevertheless, I would caution that only advisors which meet the definition of “fee-only” use that term to describe themselves in any communications with any client or any group of clients, or in any other communication.

Monday, May 18, 2015

Tibble v. Edison: Lessons for DOL Rule-making?

In a relatively brief opinion issued by the U.S. Supreme Court on May 18, 2015, the Court unanimously ruled in favor of the plan participants, remanding the case to the lower courts for further proceedings. While the decision largely merely affirms established law, the question arises as to whether the decision may influence DOL rule-making in the months ahead.

COURT DISCUSSES MUTUAL FUND FEES. “[P]articipants’ retirement benefits are limited to the value of their own individual investment accounts, which is determined by the market performance of employee and employer contributions, less expenses. Expenses, such as management or administrative fees, can sometimes significantly reduce the value of an account in a defined-contribution plan.”

As seen above, the Supreme Court noted that mutual fund expenses “can sometimes” significantly reduce the value of investment accounts. This statement can be read several different ways.

The Supreme Court noted these facts in the case: “Petitioners contend that respondents breached the duty of prudence by offering higher priced retail-class mutual funds when the same investments were available as lower priced institutional-class mutual funds.” However, the Supreme Court did not opine on this aspect of the case, nor upon the trial court’s finding that the plan sponsor “had ‘not offered any credible explanation’ for offering retail-class, i.e., higher priced mutual funds that ‘cost the Plan participants wholly unnecessary [administrative] fees,’ and [the trial court] concluded that, with respect to those mutual funds, [the plan sponsor] had failed to exercise ‘the care, skill, prudence and diligence under the circumstances’ that ERISA demands of fiduciaries.”

Nevertheless, given the clear duty of due care of an ERISA fiduciary to justify higher-cost funds, the burden is very heavy upon an ERISA fiduciary to recommend higher-cost investments when lower-cost investments are available which are substantially similar in terms of their composition, risks, and expected returns. One of the key issues for analysis of the "Best Interests Contract Exemption" is whether higher fees and costs incurred - that results in additional compensation to the broker-dealer firm or insurance company - can ever be justified under ERISA, and if so, what this justification would look like. What is the evidentiary standard for such justification to withstand scrutiny? The Supreme Court's decision does not directly address these issues, but it is clear that justification must be credible.

COURT DISCUSSES THE ERISA FIDUCIARY’S DUTY OF DUE CARE. “An ERISA fiduciary must discharge his responsibility ‘with the care, skill, prudence, and diligence’ that a prudent person ‘acting in a like capacity and familiar with such matters’ would use.”

This statement of the ERISA fiduciary’s duty of due care follows many prior decisions.

Note that the U.S. Supreme Court did not discuss the ERISA fiduciary’s duty of loyalty, nor did the Court discuss procedures to be followed under ERISA when a fiduciary possesses a conflict of interest.

COURT DISCUSSES THE ONGOING DUTY OF THE FIDUCIARY TO MONITOR INVESTMENTS. “[U]nder trust law [from which an ERISA fiduciary’s duties are derived] a fiduciary is required to conduct a regular review of its investment with the nature and timing of the review contingent on the circumstances.” The Uniform Prudent Investor Act confirms that “[m]anaging embraces monitoring” and that a trustee has “continuing responsibility for oversight of the suitability of the investments already made.” §2, Comment, 7B U. L. A. 21 (1995) (internal quotation marks omitted). Scott on Trusts implies as much by stating that, “[w]hen the trust estate includes assets that are inappropriate as trust investments, the trustee is ordinarily under a duty to dispose of them within a reasonable time.”

“Under trust law, a trustee has a continuing duty to monitor trust investments and remove imprudent ones. This continuing duty exists separate and apart from the trustee’s duty to exercise prudence in selecting investments at the outset. The Bogert treatise states that ‘[t]he trustee cannot assume that if investments are legal and proper for retention at the beginning of the trust, or when purchased, they will remain so indefinitely’ … Rather, the trustee must “systematic[ally] conside[r] all the investments of the trust at regular intervals” to ensure that they are appropriate … The Uniform Prudent Investor Act confirms that “[m]anaging embraces monitoring” and that a trustee has “continuing responsibility for oversight of the suitability of the investments already made.” §2, Comment, 7B U. L. A. 21 (1995) (internal quotation marks omitted). Scott on Trusts implies as much by stating that, “[w]hen the trust estate includes assets that are inappropriate as trust investments, the trustee is ordinarily under a duty to dispose of them within a reasonable time.”
This lengthy discussion of the scope of the ERISA fiduciary’s duty to monitor addresses the key, albeit narrow, issue in the Tibble v. Edison case, which involved when action occurs which is actionable (i.e., when action occurs which tolls the statute of limitations, within which time a claim must be brought).


This aspect of the decision reminds us that ERISA fiduciaries – firms and their representatives – possess an ongoing duty to update their due diligence as to investments previously recommended to a client, at least where the client remains a client of the firm.

IN SUMMARY. Only a small amount of guidance can be inferred from the Court's Tibble vs. Edison decision. Yet, the Court's decision can serve as a reminder of the high level of due diligence required in the selection of investments. Moreover, the Court's acknowledgement of the significant role played in mutual fund expenses in a plan participant's retirement account value will likely result in a strong focus on the type of justification required to recommend higher-cost investments, especially where higher cost investments result in greater compensation to the ERISA fiduciary (as proposed to be permitted under BICE).

Sunday, May 17, 2015

DOL Fiduciary Rule Proposal: Questions for Readers

As the DOL, with political backing from President Obama and Senator Warren (among others), ramped up efforts early this year in advance of the DOL's release of its proposed rule extending fiduciary duties, so did Wall Street and the insurance companies. Millions and millions of dollars have been flowing from broker-dealer firms, insurance companies, and others opposed to fiduciary rule-making. No surprise here.

Yet, the DOL's efforts continue. Despite an extension of the initial comment period, the DOL hearings are to be scheduled the week of August 10th, followed by another comment period, all leading to a final rule expected in early 2016.

Still, obstacles to the DOL's proposal are huge, in a city where money often sways personal, responsible judgment. There exist many ways the rule can be side-tracked in the months ahead.

Pro-fiducairy advocates largely support the DOL's proposed rule. Many consumer groups and pro-fiduciary advocates are scrutinizing the intricacies of the DOL's complex proposal, seeking to point out ways for improvement. Of particular concern is the Best Interests Contract Exemption, the terms of which remain subject to varying interpretations and concerns regarding effective enforcement.

Some fiduciary advocates have simply chosen to oppose the DOL's proposal. While I sympathize with their leaning, I do not believe that such "blanket opposition" is constructive. It is easy to say "no" to any regulation, and such opposition often leads to headlines and popular articles.

But let us not just seek publicity via blanket opposition. It is highly likely that the DOL won't "stop in its tracks." We must, accordingly, not be pure idealists, but rather undertake a more practical pursuit toward our objectives. Hence, I believe the best course is to engage with the DOL and seek to improve the rule and to close any perceived loopholes.

So, below, I seek out your insights, in response to some very specific questions.

In summary, the DOL has proposed expanding the definition of “fiduciary” and, in conjunction therewith, proposes a new “Best Interest Contract Exemption” (BICE). In essence, the BICE exemption abandons the long-standing requirement that compensation must be “level” – i.e., it authorizes the receipt of additional compensation by BD firms and insurance companies, but only if certain requirements are met. In essence, the “sole interests” standard under ERISA (which prohibits most conflicts of interests) is abandoned under BICE, in favor of a “best interests” standard which has many conditions to it.

Much has been written already which outlines the DOL's rule-making; this post does not seek to replicate such summaries, which can be found elsewhere via simple online searches. Instead, I assume the reader is familiar with the DOL's rule and with BICE, as proposed, and seek your input on some of the more intriguing questions posed by the DOL's draft rule.

Specific Questions Posed for Discussion.

1. How Can Higher-Cost, Similar Products Be Justified?  Given the substantial (and some would say “overwhelming”) academic evidence in support of the proposition that, on average, higher-fee investments underperform lower-fee investments, particularly over longer periods of time, under what circumstances would a higher-fee mutual fund (that provides additional compensation to the BD firm), possessing the same characteristics, be permitted to be recommended over a lower-fee mutual fund, under BICE?

a.     What would the “due diligence memorandum” (prepared by the BD firm, as justification for permitting such a higher-cost product to be recommended) look like, and/or contain?

b.     At its most basic level, when can differential compensation be justified for recommending one product over another product which is substantially similar in terms of its composition and risk characteristics? Does differential compensation in such circumstances create the very economic incentives, leading to conflict-ridden and poor advice, which ERISA’s sole interests standard was designed to avoid?

2. How Can Bonuses Be Awarded?  How would compensation structures change within BD firms and insurance companies? Since under the proposal bonuses to register representatives and insurance agents are not to be based upon receipt of differential compensation by the BD firm or insurance company, upon what criteria would “bonuses” be based for registered representatives and insurance agents, in a way which would not violate the requirements of BICE as to firm policies? Would firms likely adopt a largely qualitative approach to bonuses, with a “wink,” in which managers consider how much additional compensation is received by the firm as a result of a registered rep’s production, while not actually stating this in the award of bonus compensation?

A specific concern exists in the language of this example provided by the DOL in its release: “Example 5: Alignment of Interests. The Financial Institution's policies and procedures establish a compensation structure that is reasonably designed to align the interests of the Adviser with the interests of the Retirement Investor. For example, this might include compensation that is primarily asset-based … with the addition of bonuses and other incentives paid to promote advice that is in the Best Interest of the Retirement Investor. While the compensation would be variable, it would align with the customer's best interest.”

3. Changing the Relationship Between BD and RR? Tension?  How might this change the dynamic between BD firms (who possess an economic incentive to receive additional compensation, subject to certain requirements) and registered reps [who, at least according to the rule, should not (normally) be incentivized to receive additional compensation for recommending certain products over others].

4. Are VAs and EIAs More Likely to be Recommended in IRA Accounts?  Under “Example 4” the DOL provides in its release, differential compensation to the individual advisor can be justified if the time to “research and explain” annuities is more than that required for mutual funds. Given the higher amounts of commissions and other compensation generally paid in connection with many VA and EIA sales, and the inherent complexity of these products, will this example provide fuel for a large shift into VAs and EIAs, and away from lower-cost mutual funds?

 “Example 4:  Differential Payments Based on Neutral Factors. The Financial Institution establishes payment structures under which transactions involving different investment products result in differential compensation to the Adviser based on a reasonable assessment of the time and expertise necessary to provide prudent advice on the product or other reasonable and objective neutral factors. For example, a Financial Institution could compensate an Adviser differently for advisory work relating to annuities, as opposed to shares in a mutual fund, if it reasonably determined that the time to research and explain the products differed. However, the payment structure must be reasonably designed to avoid incentives to Advisers to recommend investment transactions that are not in Retirement Investors' best interest.”

In my experience, most registered reps don’t fully understand VAs and EIAs, and rarely does the client understand the true nature of the often-illusory “guarantees” of VAs nor the participation rates (and how they are computed) and caps of EIAs, and the insurance company's ultimate control over how such participation rates and caps vary from year to year.

5. How is a One-Time High Commission Amount "Reasonable"?  Suppose a client seeks to rollover a $1,000,000 401(k) account or IRA account into another IRA with an advisor. The “advisor” – acting under the BICE exemption – recommends a variable annuity (paying the firm a  or equity indexed annuity product (to avoid mutual fund breakpoints). Under many VA and EIA sales, the firm is paid a commission – perhaps 5% to 9% ($50,000 to $90,000) – up front. As a result, a surrender charge is imposed for several years should the investor withdraw funds from the annuity (usually in excess of 10% a year). Is this compensation “reasonable”? What if a lower commission is paid (say, 4%) but with trailing fees (perhaps 0.75% or so a year) for “ongoing advice” provided by the firm/registered rep or insurance agent? Should commissions be lower for VA and EIA sales - when higher amounts are invested - as is the case with breakpoints for mutual fund Class A shares?

6. Fixed Annuity, EIA Fee/Cost Determinations.  How can the fees and costs paid by an investor in a fixed income annuity, and in an equity indexed annuity, be determined, in order to satisfy the initial and annual fee/cost disclosure requirements?

7. Less Commissions, More 12b-1 Fees? Will this lead to the abandonment of Class A mutual fund shares (a trend started a decade or more ago) in larger part, in favor of Class C shares? Is this a good thing for investors? Since 12b-1 fees generally cannot be negotiated by an investor, does this present difficulties which caution the use of funds with 12b-1 fees? What if the SEC acts to limit, or even ban, 12b-1 fees in the future?

8. Does the BICE Exemption Meet the Requirements for a PTE? Under ERISA section 408(a) and Code section 4975(c), the DOL cannot grant a PTE (i.e., an exemption from the prohibited transaction rules and other ERISA requirements  unless it first finds that the exemption is administratively feasible, in the interests of plans and their participants and beneficiaries and IRA owners, and protective of the rights of participants and beneficiaries of plans and IRA owners. Is this exemption “in the interests of” investors? Is this exemption “protective of the rights” of investors?

Many other questions exist. Any insights you can provide are much appreciated.

Please comment in the box below, or e-mail me private at: WKUBear@gmail.com.

Thank you. - Ron Rhoades

Saturday, March 21, 2015

Choose to Seize All of the Marrow Out of LIfe

Henry David Thoreau wrote in his book, Walden, “I went to the woods because I wished to live deliberately … and not when I came to die discover that I had not live. I wanted to life deep and suck all the marrow out of life … to put to rout all that was not life.” While written more than a century ago, we might inquire what Henry David Thoreau might write about today. Perhaps that we know how to live life fast, but not deep. Or perhaps that we are so distracted by television, video games, and other mindless activities that we don’t actually live life at all.
EXPAND YOUR COMFORT ZONE …
Over the past few years I’ve assigned students in some of my classes various activities designed to expand their “comfort zones.” The result? While some students did not obtain all they could out of the assignment, most appeared to gain significant benefits from it. Here are a few of the comments I’ve recently received:
  •  “These experiences have taught me that it doesn’t always matter what people think about you in life. The ones who matter don’t mind, and the ones who mind don’t matter.”
  •   “What scare me most? Rejection … but now I will try to take more risks and I now understand even if someone does say no to me there is nothing wrong with that because there will always be more opportunities.”
  •  “I want to change my fixed mindset to a growth mindset.”
  •  “This assignment helped me realize how small my comfort zone really is. It forced me to do things I wouldn’t normally do and got me to expand my horizons. I think this assignment can be beneficial to whomever is doing it.”

Make the most out of your college life. Decide right now to make the next seven weeks the most impactful of your life. Choose to undertake one activity a week, from the list (see excerpt from Ron's book, below), and you can dramatically change your life for the better. You own self will love you for it!
CAN THESE VIDEOS CHANGE YOUR LIFE?
There are great pearls of knowledge and skills to be learned in the classrooms at college. But not all learning is done in the classroom; much wisdom can be found elsewhere. Hence, in addition to choosing to expand your comfort zone through the attached activities, I also suggest you team up with a friend or a family member and watch one or more of the following videos, from my personal list of favorites
Just take one hour out of your next day, and you can propel yourself down a path of greater success with the insights you obtain from these interesting, and often entertaining, short videos:

Believe in yourself. And act to become a better friend, companion, family member, student, and person – each and every day.
Carpe diem.
Thank you.
Ron A. Rhoades, JD, CFP®

Ron is a college professor, where he provides innovative instruction in financial planning and other business courses. Commencing July 2015 he will be joining the Department of Finance at Western Kentucky University, Bowling Green, KY, where he will serve as Program Director of its rapidly growing and nationally reknowned personal financial planning program.


EXPAND YOUR COMFORT ZONE
 Eleanor Roosevelt once wrote, “Do one thing each day that scares you.”
I once met two brothers, students in my class, who – despite having characteristics of introverts – were outgoing, friendly, and always willing to tackle new challenges. Having lunch with them one day, I discovered their secret. Each and every morning, as their mother sent them off to school, their mother said: “Do one thing today that scares you.”
We must realize that our brains are hard-wired, from the days of the cave men, to flee from danger. But in today’s society, where interpersonal skills are so highly valued, we need to learn to overcome fear. Otherwise fear prevents us from achieving, and it takes a far greater bite out of our life than we should permit it to do.
While not all fears should be overcome, many fears cause us to be anxious in social situations. To overcome these and related fears, each of us needs to seek to “expand our comfort zone.”
As you expand your comfort zone, you actually grow as a person to fill out these new boundaries.
If you have a larger comfort zone, and continue to push the edges of it out, you really do grow as an individual – you have more experiences, undertake more learning, and acquire more wisdom.
Understand the Need to Say “Yes”!
In the 2008 movie “Yes Man,” Jim Carrey plays Carl, who reluctantly promises to stop being a "No Man" and vows to answer "Yes!" to every opportunity, request or invitation that presents itself thereafter. While the result (in the movie) is both hilarious and, at times, moving, the movie is actually based upon a real experiment. In fact, after the movie, some individuals chose to say “Yes!” for an entire week. Here’s one blog post indicating the results: http://vladdolezal.com/blog/2009/my-real-world-yes-man-experiment/
If saying “Yes!” to everything for a week is too much of a challenge, then consider an alternative – calculated activities to expand your “comfort zone.” For much of the past 30 years, I’ve taken on the challenge of expanding my comfort zone. Being a severe introvert, I first learned how to socialize at receptions and similar events (a skill I am still working on). I began to give speeches and presentations, first to small groups; this evolved into my current ability to give speeches to a several hundred or a few thousand people at various conferences without any undue nervousness.
Each and every one of us has her or his own “comfort zone.” Studies have shown that 40% of college students possess social anxiety – i.e., shyness. And the remaining 60% possess anxiety in other circumstances, such as public speaking, meeting someone new for the first time, etc. The truth is that each and every one of us can expand their comfort zone, significantly, over time. And college is a great place to undertake this effort.
Why do this? Life’s magic occurs largely outside your current comfort zone. If you want to suck all the marrow out of life, as I do, you need to be willing to put yourself out there into areas of “discomfort.” Then, as you adjust, you become more and more comfortable in those situations, thereby expanding your comfort zone, you actually grow as a person to fill out these new boundaries.
If you develop a larger comfort zone, and continue to push the edges of it out, you really do grow as an individual – you have more experiences, undertake more learning, and acquire more wisdom.
In short, you experience life more fully.
As an added bonus, when you interview for a job in your career field you will be a better interviewee, and job candidate. The better jobs go to the graduates who are more personable and well-rounded!
Learn to Rush Toward Your Fears!
I am deathly afraid of heights, and always have been. As a child, during a visit to New York City, I was very nervous about going up the Empire State Building, and even more so when my parents urged me to peer down from the observation deck to the streets below. My fear of falling was intense; and my parents could never get me to ride any roller coaster - regardless of how small or tame it may have been.
So at the age of 18 years, I faced a dilemma. I was in my first summer at the U.S. Coast Guard Academy. I found out that on the summer cruise, in just a few weeks’ time, I would be required to climb the rigging of the tall ship, the U.S.C.G. Eagle, and to work aloft handling the sails.
While at the Coast Guard Academy I received instruction from a Boatswain's Mate, who had been in the Coast Guard for about a decade. He previously had served on the Eagle, and as he taught us various types of knots he explained where on the Eagle we might find a use for each one. As he was teaching several cadets and me the intricacies of tying a bowline (a type of knot), I asked the Boatswain’s Mate, with some apprehension in my voice, “How difficult is it to climb the Eagle's rigging?” The Boatswain's Mate paused from working the line in his hands, looked me straight in the eye, and simply said: "Rush toward your fear."
A few weeks later, my fellow swabs - that's what they called first year cadets - were flown to Miami, where we picked up the Eagle to take her on a week-long training cruise. So here I was, at the Port of Miami, aboard the docked ship, with my gear stowed.  It was an early summer evening, and I was on deck, looking up at the three masts, the 10 yardarms, the crosstrees, shrouds, halyards, and all the other rigging. As I was looking up, contemplating my fate, the Officer of the Deck approached me and asked, "Want to go aloft?"
I imagine I turned white a bit, but just then I remembered what the Boatswain’s Mate had said.  "Rush toward your fear." So I nodded to the Officer of the Deck, stowed my hat, and headed up the rigging. I climbed up the rope ladder, past the first platform and the lowest yardarm. I continued higher and higher, pausing every several steps to look around – and at times down to the deck, appearing smaller and smaller as I went higher and higher. Past two more yardarms, and finally I made it to the second and higher platform upon which I could sit, pause, and regain my senses.
But just then the Officer of the Deck shouted up, “Keep going. Touch the commissioning pennant.” I looked down, then up, terrified. The shrouds (lines running up and down) were very narrow at this point, and it was difficult to fit my big shoe in the rigging to go higher. But, keeping in mind what the Boatswain’s Mate had told me, higher I did go, the last thirty feet, and touched the commissioning pennant at the top of the mainmast, some one hundred fifty feet above the deck.
As I headed back down, I traversed out onto the footrope that hung beneath each of the yardarms. My big feet found each single footrope that hung beneath each yardarm with ease with a firm grip on the handrails affixed to each yardarm. I traversed out to the end of each yardarm, then returned back to the mast.
I also paused and sat on each platform, partly to rest and partly to enjoy the view.  In the rays of the setting summer sun, I felt a sense of accomplishment. Not only had I climbed the rigging, far beyond the point where I ever thought I would, but I was the first among my classmates to do so.
From that day forward, I was known as a “rigging rat,” always willing to go aloft to furl or unfurl the sails.
A year later, I was aboard the Eagle for a longer summer cruise, this time across the Atlantic and back. When returning, just northwest of Bermuda, the ship encountered a low-pressure system. (A better description of the low-pressure system would be “minor hurricane” – although I was not convinced that hurricanes could be minor.)
It was the middle of the night. Cadets were not allowed on deck, except for the bridge crew. The Eagle was under sail, in seventy-five knot winds, with gusts up to ninety knots. Even though it was the dead of night, the sea was awash in white, as the wind and waves combined to brew a froth of whitecaps and foam atop the thirty-foot high waves.
That night I was on duty on the ship’s helm. I led a team of six cadets, on three connected six-foot ship’s wheels, as we sought to keep the ship on course. The Eagle did not have power steering, so turning the rudder, via the wheel, required a good amount of muscle applied by the six cadets.
Only the three lower sails on each mast were deployed that night, as the top two sails had long been furled in order to not strain the masts too much. Suddenly the gaskets that constrained the topsail to the yardarm blew out. This posed a dangerous condition – not only could we lose a sail in the powerful wind, but the stress being placed on the mast by the sail flapping in the high wind could cause it to snap. If the mast snapped, it could fall to and through the deck, even punching a hole in the hull of the ship. In short, the ship was at risk.
The Captain quickly sent an experienced enlisted man aloft to secure the sail. After twenty minutes, the enlisted man signaled down that he needed more line. The Captain looked around, spotted me on the wheel, and asked: “Rhoades, want to go aloft?”
I wouldn’t say that I wanted to go aloft in those conditions. But a request from your Captain was more like a very strong suggestion, and somewhat close to an order. So I headed down to the Boatswain’s Locker, measured out eighty feet of line, cut and spliced the ends of the line, and wrapped it in a coil. With the coil of line slung over my shoulders, I headed up to the deck, crossed to the side of the ship, and in a pause between the waves crashing over the ship's side, I then grasped the rigging and headed aloft.
The Eagle, though under sail, reeled from side to side and yawed fore and aft. Climbing the rigging was instantly a challenge, for as the ship careened over onto one side I found myself not climbing vertically, but rather at times almost horizontally, looking down at the deck. Then, as the Eagle careened to its other side, I hung on, for I would find myself hanging on to the rigging, looking straight up to the sky, with all fours – and even at times with my head seemingly below my feet.
Fifteen minutes of effort later, I finally reached the top yardarm. I left the rigging and traversed out onto the footrope beneath the yardarm. There I encountered the enlisted man – the very same Boatswain’s Mate who had taught me knots more than a year before. We looked each other in the eye, and he nodded at me, with a slight smile passing his lips. I nodded back, and then together we set to work, wrapping up the sail with the line and tightly securing it to the yardarm. Some thirty minutes later, we were back on deck, exhausted from battling the high winds and sea spray as we worked aloft. Yet it was a physical exhaustion only, for our minds raced as we recalled the journey we had together pursued during the past hour.
Rush toward your fear – or you will miss out on the great experiences in life.
Today I am still afraid of heights. But I have been on roller coasters since I was eighteen years of age.  And I have gone up in many tall buildings (and even, at times, I have peeked over the edge).
If you are confronted with some fear, realize this. Whatever fear is facing you - whether it be the fear of meeting someone new for the first time, or the fear of public speaking, or some other fear in life - rush toward it. For once you are past it, life is great on the other side.
Your Assignment: 
First, watch the following TedX talk, only six minutes long: “Measuring Comfort Zones” by Marcus Taylor at TEDxMelbourne. (6 minutes).
Then, for each of the next seven weeks, choose two activities each week from the list below. Choose those activities that scare you – i.e., those activities that expand your comfort zone. Please note that you may not repeat any activity.
At the end of each week, you should write down your progress in your journal. Schedule a reminder on your smart phone for the same day and time, once a week for nine weeks, to record your journal entries.
Your journal entries might start off in the following manner:
I expanded my comfort zone over the past week by undertaking two activities I would not have normally undertaken.
For the first activity I … (Describe the activity. What was the result for you? How did it make you feel?) As a result of all of this experience, I have realized that ….
For the second activity I … (Describe the activity. What was the result for you? How did it make you feel?) As a result of all of this experience, I have realized that ….
Here are the activities to choose from:
1. Eat something different – a food item you have not tried in at least a year.
2. Give at least three people compliments on any day, when you normally would not (counts as one activity).
3. Smile at (all) strangers, and say “Good morning” or “Good afternoon” or “Hi” to all the people you pass by, for one entire day – and wherever you are!
4. Get to sleep (bed) one hour earlier for four nights straight, and at the same time each night (this counts as one activity).
5. Speak up in a class – when you normally would not speak up.
6. Go to an on-campus event or which you typically would not go to, or engage in a new activity on-campus.
7. Thank a friend or family member for their ongoing support.
8. Tell someone they are loved.
9. Let go of your self-judgment for a day. And do something others would never think you would do. Feel good about yourself. If others think ill of you – they do not matter; they are no longer part of your personal universe.
10. Peform on Karaoke night.
11. Show three friends or acquaintances the benefits of the “Power Pose” and show them the video (Google search: “TedX Power Pose”).
12. Unplug your t.v. and video games for one entire week.
13. Use the writing center on-campus for assistance in reviewing the draft of an essay or paper.
14. Do your math homework in the math lab, seeking assistance when needed.
15. Ask for a tutor.
16. Form a study group, or join one, during the next seven days.
17. See a professor for guidance on “how to do better” in a particular class, or on a particular assignment.
18. See a professor for tips or career paths and/or “how to best network to find jobs or internships.”
19. Obtain counseling at the student health center to talk through a problem or to seek ideas on how to relieve stress.
20. Apologize to someone you have done wrong / admit you were wrong.
21. Write a “personal log entry” in which you forgive someone for a wrong done to you. Let go of bitterness and anger. Let go of a grudge. (Whether you choose to communicate your forgiveness to the other person is up to you, and dependent upon the circumstances.)
22. Perform three “random acts of kindness” in one day (counts as one activity). For ideas on random acts of kindness you might undertake, Google search the term “random acts of kindness.”
23. Go up to a stranger in a student dining or coffee shop area. Introduce yourself and ask him or her if you can ask them a few questions, for an assignment you are working on. Find out the person’s name, major or occupation, hometown, and what they like most and least about the college or the program they are in.
24. Change your group of friends (i.e., don’t “lie down with dogs”), or disassociate yourself over time from one friend who tends to drag you down.
25. Undertake a civic engagement activity with others.
26. Post a “success tip” once a day, each day, or your dorm room door or another place on campus, or on your social media page, for five straight days. Make certain you indicate below the success tip your identity, such as: “This success tip provided courtesy of (your name).”
These exercises can be powerful, if you approach them with an open mind and a view toward personal growth.
Prior comments received from students include:
  •         “Some students don’t really understand the point of these exercises. But, it’s teaching the confidence that you need to survive in the business world.”
  •         “As a result of all these experiences, I have realized how important it is step outside your comfort zone.  I never realized how much you could be missing out on when you stay within your safe day-to-day routine.  Although not every experience was a pleasant one I still enjoyed all of these exercises.”
  •         “I feel that doing things which are uncomfortable can make life more worthwhile.”
  •         “I know some of these tasks might come by easy to some people, but they were hard ones for me. I realize that stepping outside your comfort zone not only builds strength, but it also helps you realize things about yourself you would have never known if you didn’t do the unusual.”
  • ·         “I would do this project one hundred times over again.”