Search This Blog

Thursday, October 30, 2014

I Am a (Fiduciary) Zealot, for I BELIEVE

I admit it. I'm a "believer." Yes, I am even a "fiduciary" zealot.

I believe when you say, "I act in my client's best interest," it means never placing your interests above that of the client. No caveats. I believe that core fiduciary duties cannot be waived by clients, nor can disclaimers of fiduciary duties be upheld as legitimate.

I believe when you say, "I provide objective advice," it means that conflicts of interest are avoided.

I believe conflicts of interest cannot just be "disclosed away," and that if a conflict of interest is unavoidable then full and complete disclosure must be affirmatively undertaken in a manner to ensure client understanding and to secure the client's informed consent, and even then that the suggested course of action remain substantively fair to the client. For no client would ever consent to harm.

I believe when you say, "I am a fiduciary," it means that you cannot push proprietary products, engage in principal trading, receive additional compensation for recommending one product over another, receive revenue sharing payments (including payments for shelf space or 12b-1 fees), or even receive soft dollar compensation.

I believe when you hold out as an advisor (as opposed to a salesperson), whether by use of the terms "financial consultant" or "financial advisor" or "financial planner" or "wealth manager" or any other similar terms, or by using designations such as CFP(r) or ChFC, you represent yourself as a trusted advisor, and should accordingly act as such at all times. I believe that holding yourself out as a trusted advisor, and not accepting fiduciary status and its burdens and restraints upon conduct, is tantamount to fraud.

I believe that each person should honestly, and forthrightly, say what he or she does, and then should do what he or she says.

I believe that once you accept fiduciary status toward a client, it extends to all aspects of your professional relationship of the client, and that the fiduciary hat cannot be removed.

I believe it is not possible to wear two hats at one time. (And a lot of jurists agree with me.)

I believe that, by either holding out as a trusted financial advisor, or acting as same, you are bound to exercise a professional level of due care, requiring expertise and experience and sound judgment.

I believe, to paraphrase the late Justice Benjamin Cardoza, that the fiduciary standard should not be diminished by "particularized exceptions" which are developed over time.

I believe that I am a steward of my clients' wealth. It is not there for me to play with. I must deal with it prudently, and wisely, applying my vast knowledge of the workings of the capital markets to seek to achieve my client's lifetime financial goals.

I believe I am a professional, and that we, as professionals, place the interests of the public ahead of our own.

I believe as a trusted expert advisor I am entitled to professional-level compensation - not more, and not less.

I believe that the application of a bona fide fiduciary standard to personalized investment advice, in this ever-more complex financial world, is inevitable. Perhaps not this year, or even this decade. Perhaps not even in my lifetime. But some day.

I believe that promotion of the fiduciary standard will continue, as advocates (such as those in The Committee for the Fiduciary Standard -  http://www.thefiduciarystandard.org/) continue to seek to aid our fellow Americans to receive the honest, trusted advice they all so richly deserve.

I believe that, following the imposition of a bona fide fiduciary standard for all providers of financial and investment advice, the demand for financial planning and investment advice will soar, Americans will become more trusting of the capital markets, the cost of capital will decline, and fuel will be provided to propel America's economy forward.

I believe in the Fiduciary Oath. http://www.fi360.com/main/pdf/fiduciaryoath_individual.pdf. I believe every single consumer of financial and investment advice should absolutely insist upon the signature of his or her financial or investment advisor to such oath.

I believe that fairness will prevail over greed, right over wrong, and trust over betrayals of trust.

I believe.

I will continue to believe.

Ron A. Rhoades, JD, CFP(r) serves as Asst. Professor in the Business Department at Alfred State College, where he serves as Curriculum Coordinator for its Financial Planning Program. To learn more about Ron, please view http://www.alfredstate.edu/users/rhoadera

Saturday, October 11, 2014

A Walk with Grandfather, 20 Years Ago

On a cool Spring morning in Chapel Hill, North Carolina, Grandfather's pace quickened as the hill was crested. His wooden walking staff, at six feet long nearly as tall as Grandfather's slightly stooped frame, cracked with an escalating rhythm upon the granite street as we approached the park.

Grandfather paused before entering upon the dirt path ahead. Reaching down he picked a fresh green leaf from a small tree. Holding the solitary leaf up in the yellow light of the early morning sun, his eyes peered through the thick lenses of his black-rimmed eyeglasses as he sensed the leaf's light green color. His finger gently traversed the texture leaf's spine and ribs. Slowly he turned, handing me the leaf, his gaze now directed at my eyes. Clutching the leaf, I resumed my place to his left as he turned right to resume his daily sojourn down the pebbled path of the park.

As I approached mid-life, I began to sense a lack of purpose in my life. Many wonderful experiences I had enjoyed, such as the birth of my children, my wedding day, and graduations and the sense of accomplishment each had brought forth. I had been blessed with the experience of sailing across the Atlantic and back on a barkentine. I treasured the trophies and awards obtained in both team and individual sports and endeavors - rowing, football, track, and the rifle drill team competitions. Yet, more recently, I began to reflect upon whether the choices I had made led a a life which would be, ultimately, devoid of fulfillment.

So I turned to the wisest man I knew, traveling to the home of my maternal Grandfather, John Ferguson. Born in Scotland just before the end of the 19th Century, he survived a journey as an infant on a sailing ship to South Africa, where his own father, a pharmacist, had decided to settle. Like me he was an avid reader throughout his life, which no doubt had a role in Grandfather's attainment as a Rhodes scholar. He pursued a career in medicine, eventually teaching at Harvard, Michigan, and Alabama before landing his own family in Chapel Hill, North Carolina. There he taught, undertook pioneering research in blood chemistry, and wrote books and many scholarly papers.

Now long retired, having outlived two wives, he lived alone near the campus of the University of North Carolina. Distinguished with his silver hair and warm smile, he continued to write, and occasionally traveled in pursuit of additions to his collection of 30,000 shells from around the world. His six children and thirteen grandchildren visited him often, though nearly all had scattered to distant parts of the country.

I, myself, had now traveled north from Florida to enjoy once again my Grandfather's company. I knew I would be entertained with a game of shuffleboard on the court nestled in a small garden near his back door. I knew I would enjoy another perusal of his vast collection of books, and that I would savor the Earl Grey tea and biscuits he served each afternoon.

Yet, I was also there to pose him a most serious question. Not long after my morning arrival for a day-long visit, Grandfather senses my unease. Never one to pry, he ate his breakfast mostly in silence, as if he knew an inquiry would be forthcoming.

After the breakfast of eggs, bacon and toast was consumed, I began. "Grandfather, I have come to you with a personal concern." Grandfather's eyes were warm and inquisitive, as I continued. "Each day in my law practice I see clients who have been taken advantage of. It seems as if greed has conquered reason. I see the damages. And I see the resulting suffering. I wonder if I made the right choices. Should I have followed in your footsteps, and become a healer and a researcher? Have I made a great mistake?"

Grandfather sipped the last of his coffee, saying nothing for a while. My heart pounded as I waited; each passing minute seemed like an hour. Rising and clearing his dishes from the table, he said, "Come join me for my morning walk." He then proceed to done his tweed coat and he took ahold of his walking stick.

At 94 years of age, Grandfather would likely outpace many half his age. As we ventured forth into the park, the path proceeding down a slight decline before rising again up another hill, I found myself somewhat winded as I struggled to maintain his pace. Finally, a full thirty minutes from the start of our walk, Grandfather halted beneath a tree at the top of the hill. The crisp breeze of an early April morning cooled us, as he began his lesson.

"Opportunism abounds," he stated, as he gazed over the skyline of the distant university. "It has always been such, and it will always be. At times altruism fails, and greed becomes more prevalent. But not all opportunism is bad; the profit motive drives part of humanity forward. Ethical standards counter opportunism, especially for professions. The relations of men evolve over time, always seeking the proper balance for the times in which we find ourselves. These are things you cannot control. But you can influence where the balance should lie, as humanity proceeds down its path."

I reflected upon his words, seeking to commit each one to memory. There was truth there ... control the things you can control, and do not worry about those matters outside one's ability to alter. Seek to influence the laws and rules and mores which govern the relations of men, in order to better achieve the desired balance between capitalism with no regulation and a society in which ethical standards constrain conduct.

After a time, Grandfather continued, now addressing my primary question. His answer to my concern regarding my career choice was unexpected. He began, "Each week when I go to the grocery store, I make certain I depart through Joan's check-out line. And each week I am greeted by her smile, pleasant demeanor, and expression of gratitude as I complete my purchase. I note that her line always seems the longest at the store, for there are other regulars who also frequent her.  Although it is not required of her, each and every day, with her smile and expressions, Joan makes a positive impact on the lives if others."

Grandfather paused at the top of a hill, his gaze surveying the landscape around him. "One need not be a physician to do good in this world. The sanitation worker performs an essential function, and he contributes as well at the leader of a bible study at his church. The young single mother who lives down the street works hard, and struggles financially, yet still waves as she passes me by in her car in the way to work each morning, and she endeavors to provide her children with a youth full of vibrant experiences and instilled values."

Pausing his teachings for several moments, Grandfather then turned to face me. Looking into my eyes, he said, "Each of us was provided with certain gifts. Those gifts are not all the same. You need not become me, in order to accomplish great things in your life. The key is this ... discover your unique gifts, and use them to make as positive an impact upon as many as you can, in the limited time you possess upon this earth."

Reflecting upon what seemed at once magical words of wisdom from one I so admired, I accompanied Grandfather home, again challenged to maintain his walking pace. With every fourth step his walking can tapped the pavement. After returrning to his home, I enjoyed the rest of the day with him, as he explained shells from his collection and shared biscuits and tea. I enjoyed his company in the warmth if his rustic old home.

Many years have passed since that day, and Grandfather's subsequent passing a few years later. Since that day I discovered that my conversation with Grandfather that Spring morning was the beginning of a journey of self-discovery. These years have been an exploration of the motivations behind our lives, a rewarding search for illumination for insights into the human condition, and a renewed desire for self-improvement aided by self-reflection as well as insights from others in the world.

My journey these past twenty years has been filled with the passion flowing grom the growth of personal relationships. I have possessed the opportunity to share wisdom, and to motivate others, thereby enabling others to succeed. I have also sought further self-illumination through an exploration of wisdom, both ancient and contemporary. And, as Grandfather, suggested, I have used the gifts bestowed upon me to assist in the promotion of a cause (although much work remains to be done).

I have, in the process, found more happiness than I ever thought possible. I discovered a zest for life, which continues to this day. I have found treasure in the many relationships, both personal and professional, I have formed. I have found new depth in the relationships with family. I have given of myself; yet I received back from others more than I ever thought possible.

Thank you, Grandfather, for influencing me so greatly.

Tuesday, October 7, 2014

Tibble v. Edison Reviewed by U.S.SupCt - But Are the Right Facts Being Considered?

During its 2014-15 term, the U.S. Supreme Court will hear arguments on the following issue in the case of Tibble v. Edison: "Whether a claim that ERISA plan fiduciaries breached their duty of prudence by offering higher-cost retail-class mutual funds to plan participants, even though identical lower-cost institution-class mutual funds were available, is barred by 29 U. S. C. §1113(1) when fiduciaries initially chose the higher-cost mutual funds as plan investments more than six years before the claim was filed.”

I find the U.S. Department of Justice's arguments in Tibble v. Edison persuasive:  .

Yet, what bothers me at first glance, from a reading of the U.S. Department of Justice's brief (in support of Supreme Court review of this issue), is the lack of understanding as to why ERISA plan sponsors must review plan investment choices periodically, and hence the lack of arguments made over this point. The reasons are numerous:

  1. Mutual funds can change their investment strategies over time;
  2. Fund managers can change;
  3. Investment companies and their investment advisers may deserve heightened scrutiny due to legal concerns and/or compliance violations; and
  4. Over time fees and costs within a fund can change - by action of the investment adviser, by an increase or decrease in portfolio turnover rate, by larger market impact costs (either due to the fund's increased size, or for index funds because other funds may now be tracking the same index). 
Even if the risk attributes and investment strategies and fees and costs of the fund stay the same, mutual fund management does not exist in a vacuum.

For example, economies of scale may exist with the mutual fund industry and/or better, lower-cost service providers may be secured, which cause mutual funds' annual expense ratios to decline over time. Competitive forces may drive down management or other fees throughout the mutual fund industry. If no due diligence is undertaken by the plan sponsor, the plan participants will end up overpaying, to their detriment.

Additionally, new investment strategies emerge. The investment strategy followed by a fund may be disproven by new research, or simply unable to maintain an advantage due to a rush of investors (or other fund managers) to also use the strategy. New investment strategies will appear which take advantage of new insights from academic research.

The arguments by Edison in this case revolve around the langauge of the statute - i.e., that the 6-year statute of limitations runs from the date of an "action" undertaken by the plan sponsor. But such is a very narrow view of "action." Due diligence is required on an ongoing basis. (At least annually, in my view - although in this case the plan's board of trustees met quarterly.) If there exists a duty of due care, which includes prudence and due care, then that duty is met by an action taking place; othersie the duty of due care is not fulfilled. Fulfilling the duty of due care requires that a decision take place, by the plan sponsor. Even a decision to not change the fund line-up is an "act" - in this regard.

I hope that the facts brought forth at the trial in the Tibble v. Edison case permit these arguments to be made, as to why a continuing duty to monitor investment choices by an ERISA plan fiduciary exists. And I hope that the U.S. Department of Justice, or the appellants, or others permitted to file amicus briefs, will be able to argue these points.

Ron A. Rhoades, JD, CFP(r) serves as Program Director of the Financial Planning Program at Alfred State College, Alfred, New York. He also serves as 2013-4 Chair of the Steering Group of The Committee for the Fiduciary Standard. He may be reached at RhoadeRA@AlfredState.edu.


Sunday, October 5, 2014

Gresham's Dynamic: Why Bad Actors Dominate Financial Services

Economist George Akerlof wrote about “Gresham’s dynamic” in his famous 1970 article, "The Market for Lemons: Quality Uncertainty and the Market Mechanism." This paper by discussed information asymmetry, which occurs when the seller knows more about a product than the buyer. (A lemon is a slang term for a car that is found to be defective only after it has been bought.) Later, Akerlof, Michael Spence, and Joseph Stiglitz jointly received the Nobel Memorial Prize in Economic Sciences in 2001 for their research related to asymmetric information.

In his paper, Akerlof wrote: “Dishonest dealings tend to drive honest dealings out of the market. The cost of dishonesty, therefore, lies not only in the amount by which the purchaser is cheated; the cost also must include the loss incurred from driving legitimate business out of existence.” Akerlof posited that Gresham’s Law – or Gresham’s Dynamic as he employed it and called it – wasn’t just related to money; it also applied to all businesses. In essence, businesses run with bad ethics tend to drive those who possess good ethics out of the market. Obviously, this is not the result our society desires.

What can counter Greham's Dynamic? Fiduciary duties are critical means of countering the problem of information asymmetry in the financial markets. Given that information symmetry is so vast, no amount of disclosure can empower consumers to make good choices.

In fact, academic research has revealed that not only do consumers possess behavioral biases which prevent the effectiveness of disclosures, but also that the sell-side of financial services industry is trained to take advantage of these shortcomings. In essence, Wall Street adores consumers, and trains its work force to construct relationships based on trust and confidence with its customers in order to sell expensive and poor investment products. This is why a bona fide fiduciary standard, applying the principles set forth in SEC vs. Capital Gains Research Bureau (the seminal 1963 U.S. Court decision in this area), requires much more than mere disclosure of a conflict of interest. You simply cannot disclose away your core fiduciary obligation of loyalty. Because no client would provide informed consent to be harmed.

There is a solution, however, to the problem of actors with bad ethics dominating the financial services industry. This solution finds its existence throughout the history of capitalism. It is simply this - the existence of fiduciaries enable consumers of financial products and services to hire trusted experts. These experts are "purchaser's representatives" equipped with the knowledge and skill to discern good investment products from bad investment products. They use this skill not in self-dealing activities fostered by bad ethics, but under the good ethics promulgated by the fiduciary standard of conduct.

Hence, the solution to the problem of vast information asymmetry in the financial markets can be found with the application of a principles-based fiduciary standard of conduct. It imposes a restraint on greed which no other form of regulation can accomplish. Perhaps this is why the fiduciary standard is opposed by Wall Street and its proxies so vehemently.

While the solution seems simple, the background against which regulation should be taking place is quite muddy. The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), long ago captured by the very industry it regulates, has steadily weakened the fiduciary duties of investment advisers over time. It now permits core fiduciary obligations to be waived by consumers (despite the anti-waiver requirement found in the express language of the Investment Advisers Act of 1940). The SEC, incapable of seeing the limits of disclosure, permits dual registrants to disclose away conflicts of interest, with no requirement that the transaction continue to be in the best interests of the consumer. [For more on this inappropriate disclaimer of fiduciary duties, see my prior post.]

Under pressure from Wall Street, the SEC has also been most hesitant to apply fiduciary duties to the advisory relationships of brokers who provide personalized investment advice. [For more on this point, visit my post on the undue influence of Wall Street at the SEC.] As of early October 2014, the SEC has delayed decision on this issue again, as yet another economic analysis is now being undertaken by the agency. Let us hope that the economic analysis will focus not on the cost/benefits to Wall Street - we know Wall Street firms will shrink over time if broad, bona fide fiduciary standards are imposed. Let us hope, instead, that the economic analysis will focus on the capital markets and investor protection - the SEC's mandates. As I have written about previously, the fiduciary standard is pro-growth, pro-business, and pro-consumer. In fact, it is essential for the future economic health of our economy, and it is essential to better secure the financial futures of our fellow Americans.

Sadly, I don't have much confidence that the SEC will act anytime soon, or that if it acts that it will reverse its course over the past few decades and apply a bona fide, non-waivable fiduciary standard upon all those financial and investment advisers in relationships of trust and confidence with their clients. The result will be many more Aunt Beas, whose financial futures are ruined by betrayals of trust and poor ethical standards.

There is possible help for some consumers, potentially coming from the courageous Phyllis Borzi at the U.S. Dept. of Labor. In early 2015 we hope that the Administration will permit the DOL to release for comment new rules which we hope will apply a strict fiduciary standard of conduct to advisors of defined contribution plans (i.e., 401ks, etc.) and IRA accounts. However, even this proposal may never see the light of day due to huge Wall Street financial contributions to the campaign coffers of those in Congress, and due to their influence at the White House and U.S. Department of the Treasury.

What can consumers do? Ask the right questions. Unfortunately, to find a financial and/or investment advisor who is truly committed to your best interests, and who eschews conflicts of interests (and their detrimental effects on consumers), involves a "deep dive" into the advisor's business practices. Consumers - the SEC won't protect you. So, consumers, ask the right questions to find one of those few thousand investment advisers who, despite Gresham's Dynamic, have not been driven from the marketplace.

Ron A. Rhoades, J.D., CFP(r) serves as Chair of the Steering Group of The Committee for the Fiduciary Standard, whose "Fiduciary Oath" should be required of all those who provide personal financial advice. See http://www.thefiduciarystandard.org/fiduciary-oath/ 

For a longer checklist consumers can use - to ask the tough questions, visit this article on this blog: http://scholarfp.blogspot.com/2013/05/how-to-choose-financialinvestment.html 

Ron is Asst. Prof. of Business at Alfred State College, where he serves as Program Chair for its Financial Planning Program. Ron may be contacted at RhoadeRA@AlfredState.edu. 

Friday, October 3, 2014

Unsafe at Nearly Any Speed - Why I No Longer Cheer on My Beloved Football Teams

I loved football.

I played football - on offense (wide receiver) and defense (defensive end) and special teams. I enjoyed every minute of playing. I got hurt several times, but I got back up and kept playing; so much was my love of the game.

I coached high school football, for a brief period of time, as an assistant coach under the late John Rauch, after he retired as head coach of the Oakland Raiders and took a high school coaching job to "get out of the house." He was an impressive mentor.

I loved watching college football. My beloved Florida Gators football team drew my attention faithfully nearly every Saturday in the Fall. When I resided in Florida I attended at least one game a year, and sometimes several. For over 30 years I have cheered on my Florida Gators, through good times (of which there have been many) and through not-so-impressive seasons.

I enjoyed pro football, as well, and watched the occassional game. Each year for as long as I can remember I would root for one or more teams in the playoffs, and I enjoyed the spectacle of the Super Bowl.

I also, on occasion, would attend local high school football games, cheering on one team and its players - often children of friends of mine.

But no more. I will neither attend, nor watch, any more football games.

I will not follow the scores, nor the rankings.

I am sad ...

"Why?" - you may ask, would I eschew the sport that I love.

Because I can no longer rationalize that my pleasure, derived from participants in the sport, is worth the costs - the damage which occurs to the brains of the players.

While the research varies, studies show that football players are far, far more likely to develop brain trauma-related illness than non-players. And studies show that the risk to high school students is far greater than that to college athletes.

As the truth about football - and the effect of concussions as well as sub-concussive hits on the minds of players - has become known, I find myself worrying about the players in the trenches, who bash helmet against helmet on nearly every play. The joy of the game is gone.

A week before I wrote this post I was attending a college football game. Fans cheered with every score and big play. The second loudest cheers seemed to be for "big hits" - when a player was blindsided or blacked or tackled with such force that he was left on the ground. A few players in the game were, as a result, very slow to get up. Some only arose with the aid of athletic trainers. As others cheered on the big hits, I found myself extremely uncomfortable - both in viewing the hit, and with regard to the cheering which occurred around me.

But wait, you say. Are not the NFL and NCAA are going to find ways to make the game safer? They have. Helmet technology has improved. More helmets have been designed which score "5" on a scale of 1-5. (Yet, if one were to award helmets a "10" for full protection of the brain, I doubt even these better helmets would score at "2.") Also, rules have been changed to better protect players.

But the undeniable truth is that mass times acceleration equals force. The number of "big hits" may be declining due to rule changes. Helmet technology has improved. Yet, both concussive and  subconcussive hits continue to affect that most soft of organs, the brain.

Football is a sport that is unsafe at nearly any speed.

I remember when Princess Diana was killed, while in the back seat of a Mercedes Limo. While she traveled in a well-built and safe car with all kinds of safety systems (seatbelts and air bags among them), Mercedes opined about the accident something like: "No amount of engineering and safety measures can defeat the laws of physics."

But, you opine - the players know the risks; they choose to play anyway and get paid millions! The reality is that, until recently, many professional players were not aware of the risks. And college players and high school players don't get paid, at all.

So here's a question ... if you are a parent, and permit your child to play football, are you guilty of negligence?

Of course, you might say that football develops character. I concur wholeheartedly. But so do other sports that have none of the long-term, insidious effects of football on so many of its participants.

Other sports also serve to create jobs, and unite communities. If I, and many others, simply shift our support (as fans) to other sport teams, jobs will continue, and communities will remain united.

I simply cannot provide support to a business (and that is what professional football, and much of college football, is today) that does so much harm to so many of its participants. If I were to continue my support, as a fan, I would be guilty of contributing to unnecessary harm imposed on others, for my own self-enjoyment.

I will miss football. I will miss it dearly.

Ron A. Rhoades, JD, CFP(r) is an Assistant Professor of Business at Alfred State College, Alfred, NY. He is also an attorney (Florida), financial planner, and investment adviser. To learn more about Ron, please visit http://www.alfredstate.edu/users/rhoadera. 

UPDATE ... after several days, I've been successful. I don't even know the scores of last weekend - even for my beloved Florida Gators football team. It may take me some time to overcome the feelings of withdrawal, but the cause is a just one.

UPDATE ... Many articles and blog posts are appearing on this subject. Including ... http://www.tinadupuy.com/column/unsafe-at-any-speed/ ... which notes a recent study stating: "New helmets are not going to prevent new cases of CTE."

UPDATE ... another academic study 11/24/14: "In the NFL, other professional sports and especially school sports, concern has grown about the long-term neuropsychiatric consequences of repeated mild Traumatic Brain Injury (mTBI) and specifically sports-related concussive and sub-concussive head impacts." Discussed at: "Football players found to have brain damage from mild 'unreported' concussions" http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2014/11/141124103227.htm

UPDATE ... "researchers from Wake Forest Baptist Medical Center in Winston-Salem, N.C., say some high school football players in the study exhibited measurable brain changes after a single season of play, even in the absence of concussion." http://time.com/3611146/football-head-impacts-can-cause-brain-changes-even-without-concussion/

UPDATE ... another academic study, on the effect of trauma on the brain - how it interferes (over the long term) with the brain's waste removal system, possibly (probably?) leading to the onset of CTE, Alzheimers', etc.  http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2014/12/141202183311.htm

UPDATE ... "[I]t was thought that only concussions could result in any meaningful harm. New studies indicate, however, that “repeated blood-brain barrier disruption(s)” can result in brain damage. Even if football players never suffer a concussion, they’re still at severe risk of permanent brain injury. According to the Sports Concussion Institute, football is the most common sport with concussion risk for males with a 75 percent chance ... The questions remains: Are we willing to accept these risks for a game?"   http://www.dailynebraskan.com/opinion/tonkin-nebraska-should-ban-college-football-to-prevent-brain-injuries/article_7fa001f2-7b6c-11e4-8fa8-f3a70b39df93.html

UPDATE ... "Knock to the Head: A High School Football Player's Story of Traumatic Brain Injury" (Dec. 8, 2014) " The first thing to know about concussions is that they occur far more often than you might think. According to a study conducted by the National Center for Injury Prevention, 47 percent of high school football players are diagnosed with a concussion each season, with 35 percent of those reporting multiple concussions in a single season. But those statistics are just the tip of the iceberg. Saying that the number of concussions that occur each year in high school football can be represented by the number of concussions that were diagnosed by doctors is like saying that the number of Americans that speed in their cars per year can be represented by the number of people who have received speeding tickets. The reality is a lot more drivers are speeding, and a lot more football players are receiving concussions. The American College of Sports Medicine estimates that some 85 percent of concussions go undiagnosed." http://www.huffingtonpost.com/journey-bailey/high-school-football-concussions_b_6289572.html

UPDATE ... " Half of Americans Don't Want Their Sons Playing Football, Poll Shows" (Dec. 10, 2014)  http://www.bloomberg.com/politics/articles/2014-12-10/bloomberg-politics-poll-half-of-americans-dont-want-their-sons-playing-football

UPDATE ... Bloomberg, "Even Mike Ditka Thinks Football is Too Dangerous," http://www.bloombergview.com/articles/2015-01-20/even-mike-ditka-thinks-football-is-too-dangerous

UPDATE ... Boston University Study: Age of first exposure to football and later-life cognitive impairment in former NFL players, "There is an association between participation in tackle football prior to age 12 and greater later-life cognitive impairment measured using objective neuropsychological tests. These findings suggest that incurring repeated head impacts during a critical neurodevelopmental period may increase the risk of later-life cognitive impairment" http://www.espn.go.com/pdf/2015/0128/otlBUfootballstudy.pdf

UPDATE ... Repeated head blows linked to smaller brain volume, slower processing speeds http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2015/01/150129185147.htm (boxers, martial arts)


Sunday, September 28, 2014

Evidence of Harm, Part 2: "Suitability"?

The 90-year old widow, Mary, a client of my estate planning law firm, was upset. Not at me. Nor at her family. Rather, she was upset at her broker.

The week before she went to her broker. The broker suggested that she annuitize a significant portion of her investment portfolio. The client was already substantially invested in a variable annuity, sold by the same broker to that client eight years before. The existing variable annuity, if it had been annualized over life with a ten-year certain as provided under the terms of the contract, would have yielded a nice monthly check for my client.

But the broker suggested something different. Rather than annuitize the existing annuity, which would have resulted in little or no compensation to the broker, the broker suggested a tax-free exchange into a new, immediate annuity. Again a life annuity with a 10-year certain. He described it as  "better product" to the client. Trouble was, the monthly check was significantly less. In fact, the rate of return over the 10-year guarantee period was only 1%. Of course, the client could live longer, past age 100, but the client's family history and current health indicated that such a possibility was very unlikely.

The client had come to me for a review of the transaction. She thought something might be wrong, but she was uncertain.

As I delved into the details, I could find no good reason for the tax-free exchange from the existing annuity into a new annuity. Both insurance companies were highly rated. The annuitization of the existing variable annuity had no downside, and would have resulted in a better return to the client - and a larger monthly check.

The only reason for the new annuity was the fact that the broker would receive compensation - which was substantial. Hence, the lower rate of return to the client.

I wrote to the brokerage firm on behalf of the client, relaying the results of my investigation, and requesting that they undo the transaction. The reply was a one-page letter from their legal department stating that the transaction was "suitable" for the client and that the broker acted "in accord with the law."

The securities litigation firm I had consulted on behalf of the client indicated that pursuit of the claim through arbitration was unlikely to lead to a ruling in favor of the client. If the client pursued a claim in arbitration, the client would not only have to pay fees for her own attorney but could be liable for fees of the brokerage firm's attorney.

As is the case with many elderly clients, my client did not want to pursue the matter further.  No complaint would be filed with the state insurance commission. No submission of the matter to arbitration. I didn't blame her.

What my client never could grasp was that her broker was a salesperson, nothing more. While she told me she "trusted" her broker, she was unaware that she could not rely upon his advice. No fiduciary duty existed to provide good advice. As a result, the elderly widow was subject to the broker's whims. Even after the broker had done this to her, she described him as a "nice young man" who "should be forgiven for his mistake."

A few years after this incident the client died. She could have lived those last few years with a bit more financial security, and with the ability to visit her family more often. But this was denied to her, due to the inappropriate and self-serving "advice" provided to her by her broker.

The reality is that "suitability" is a doctrine that was designed to alleviate liability for executing transactions in individual stocks. Under the suitability doctrine, the duty of due care of the broker is abrogated to a significant degree. While perhaps appropriate for transaction-only services, the doctrine has been extended in recent decades to the advice given by brokers with regard to the selection of pooled investment vehicles, such as variable annuity sub-accounts and mutual funds. With no duty of due care, brokers are free to recommend bad (and expensive) investment products. With conflicts of interest persisting in the brokerage industry, brokers possess substantial incentives to behave poorly. The temptation of additional or greater commissions (or other forms of compensation) is simply too great for most to resist.

Brokers hide behind this suitability veil. It permits them to give poor advice to their customers, in ways that permit conflicts of interest to be ignored and, as a result, harm to result to their customers, over and over again.

As study after study has shown, customers believe brokers act in the customer's best interests. They are led to this conclusion through a confusing array of titles ("financial consultant," "wealth manager," etc.), designations ("Chartered Financial Consultant," etc.), and broker-dealer advertising that creates reasonable expectations that the advice provided will be objective. Sadly, in most instances, customers do not receive the trusted advice they desire, need, and reasonably expect to receive.

It's time for the fiduciary standard. For all providers of financial and investment advice. Our fellow citizens - from 90-year old widow Mary attempting to manage their nest eggs, to newly married couples beginning to save for their future financial needs - deserve no less.

Ron A. Rhoades, JD, CFP(r) is the Program Director for the Financial Planning Program at Alfred State College, Alfred, NY. He also serves as 2014 Chair of the Steering Group of the Committee for the Fiduciary Standard, a group of volunteer leaders of the financial planning profession dedicated to the proposition that all Americans deserve to be provided investment and financial advice under a bona fide fiduciary standard of conduct. Ron may be reached by e-mail at: RhoadeRA@alfredstate.edu.

Wednesday, September 24, 2014

A Simple Solution to Fiduciary Rulemaking at the SEC

Fiduciary opponents bemoan possible rulemaking at the SEC in which brokers who provide "personalized investment advice" would be subject to broad fiduciary duties (including due care, loyalty, and utmost good faith) currently applicable to investment advisers (pursuant to the Investment Advisers Act of 1940).

Fiduciary advocates worry that the SEC will choose not to apply fiduciary standards - or even worse, adopt a "new federal fiduciary standard" based upon disclosure of conflicts of interest. Fiduciary advocates correctly point out that disclosure of a conflict of interest is not enough - informed consent must occur, and no client would likely ever provide informed consent to be harmed. In other words, even with informed consent, conflicts of interest must be managed properly in order that the best interests of the client remain paramount - a matter of "substantive fairness."

What will the SEC do?

There is a simple, elegant solution. It is found in state common law, which serves to inform federal common law. The SEC can merely adopt the following rule: "Any registered representative of a broker-dealer, and its firm, become a fiduciary to its customer when a relationship of trust and confidence is formed."

After promulgating this simple statement, the SEC could let the courts determine when a relationship of trust and confidence arises. There is already a body of common law around this issue.

Of course, further guidance will likely be needed from the SEC, over time, to ensure that fiduciary obligations are not attempted to be circumscribed by the actions of broker-dealers. Such as:
  • The contract with the client does not determine whether a relationship of trust and confidence exist. Substance trumps form.
  • No client may waive the application of fiduciary status when a relationship of trust and confidence exist.
  • Core fiduciary obligations cannot be disclaimed, nor waived by the client. Estoppel and waiver possess limited application to most fiduciary relationships. (Even the "contractualist view" of fiduciary standards, as expressed by Easterbrook, acknowledges that the core fiduciary duty of loyalty cannot be waived by client consent. The contractualist view of fiduciary obligations is better suited to situations where the parties do not possess vast information asymmetry, such as might be found in the formation of a partnership.)
  • Certain narrow limits on the scope of an engagement are permitted (such as the duration of the engagement).
  • Once a relationship of trust and confidence is formed, it extends to all aspects of the relationship. (No wearing of two hats at the same time can occur.)
  • Once a relationship of trust and confidence is formed, the "fiduciary hat" cannot be removed if any advice (including product recommendations) is to be provided to the client.
  • While a registered representative may also possess a fiduciary duty to her or his broker-dealer firm, this obligation is secondary to the fiduciary duty which the registered representative and the firm owe to the client, when a relationship of trust and confidence exists.
Also, a great deal of education will be required of broker-dealer firms and their registered representatives. It can take quite an effort to instill a fiduciary culture within a firm, especially when there is a sales culture already embedded in such firm. Extensive training, from the top to the bottom, is necessary.

Ron A. Rhoades, J.D., CFP, is an Assistant Professor of Business at Alfred State College, Alfred, NY. He also serves as Chair of the Steering Group of The Committee for the Fiduciary Standard, a volunteer group of industry leaders who commit parts of their time and treasure to advocate for the application of the fiduciary standard to all providers of investment and financial advice. Ron can be reached by e-mail at RhoadeRA@AlfredState.edu.  Web site: http://www.alfredstate.edu/users/rhoadera 

Friday, September 19, 2014

The Fall 2014 Comfort Zone Challenge for College Students

College students ... 

Do you want a well-paying job? You must become well-rounded!

Do you want a successful life, in every sense of the word? You must expand your boundaries to find all that life has to offer.

College is a great place to transform yourself. Why? Because what have you got to lose? If someone judges you, just move on … you’ll likely not see them again (and they don’t need to be part of your personal universe any more). There are plenty of persons who will like you for who you are, and who will appreciate the fact that you are committed to continuous self-improvement.

All it takes is an active effort on your part to extend, just a bit each day, your Comfort Zone.

Will you take on the challenge to “Expand Your Comfort Zone” – by doing one thing each day that scares you? 

Many of your fellow students have chosen to expand their comfort zones. After tackling the exercises (see attached document), they wrote about their experiences. Here are insights from your fellow students:

“I was challenged by my Business Law professor to open my eyes and explore new things I have never thought to accomplish before. He handed us a list of 26 expand your comfort zone ideas to help us open new horizons in our personality. When he first handed this list to me I felt extreme anxiety because I do not like going outside my comfort zone.”

“Life Is Either A Daring Adventure, Or It Is Nothing.”

“This assignment was nothing like anything I have ever done before. When I first got this assignment I was very nervous about all of this and felt like I just did not want to do it. I am very glad that I did this assignment as it has allowed me to open my eyes and grow more. I feel better about being more open to new things because they were not nearly as scary as I imagined they would be and left me feeling great.”

“By expanding your comfort zone, you are giving yourself access to all that life has to offer. You only have one life to live, live it to the fullest everyday with no regrets.”

GETTING TO SLEEP ONE HOUR EARLIER

“Who knew something so little could act so big; I definitely did not.”

“An extra hour of sleep can change your entire day.”

“I have been able to pay more attention in class and I am no longer a zombie walking around campus. Overall I am surprised about the outcome of this, I didn’t think that there would be any different results at all.”

PERFORMING RANDOM ACTS OF KINDNESS

“I told a stranger to come sit with my friends and me while we were eating lunch. He seemed pretty content being alone, and I was very skeptical of bothering him at first. I got up anyway and told him to come grab a seat with a few friends and me. He responded ‘Sure, I’d love to,’ and he pulled over a chair. We all ended up chatting for over an hour and decided to hang out that weekend … If I never approached him, I wouldn’t have met someone with whom I have so much in common with and who can potentially become one of my greatest friends.”

“The last act of kindness that I did was inviting a very shy, introverted girl in my class to come hang out with my roommate and me over the weekend. She seemed surprised by my offer … we could just hang out and watch movies, instead of going out. I didn’t think she would come, but sure enough I received a text asking if she could stop by for a bit. I was glad she came by because she ended up being a ton of fun, and she undoubtedly broke out of her shell by the end of the evening.”

VISITING THE WRITING CENTER

“What I especially liked about my experience in the writing center was that he did not hand the answers over to me. My proctor explained my problems and had me find them myself which further improved my learning process. I definitely see myself going there again and again!”

OBTAINING A TUTOR

“I have never had a tutor before in my entire life so going to ask for a tutor at the Student Success Center was actually very humbling.”

MEETING SOMEONE NEW

“I went into CDH and randomly sat with a group of freshman. They were happy to have me hang out with them. We spoke about their experience so far and what they have planned for the future. Although our maturity levels were different, they made me feel welcomed. They showed me that college students are always enthusiastic to meet new people.”

FORGIVING ANOTHER PERSON

“I wrote a letter addressed to my [relative] about how this is the time of my life where I let go of all the resentment, anger, and bitterness that has been built up toward her over the years. Writing this letter really helped me channel some deep, inner emotions that I haven’t connected with in years. As I was sitting in front of the computer, I felt a wave of every emotion come crashing down on me, anxiousness being one of them. I did not know what to expect from this exercise. After writing the letter, I had felt as if this weight was lifted off my chest.”

ATTEND AN EVENT ON CAMPUS

“The first activity that I attended was the ‘Night on the Green.’ I sat outside for the live concert and then decided to stay for the movie. I’m usually the last person to get involved on a college campus, but this activity turned out to be a lot more exciting than I expected. I met a ton of people from my major and even some from my hometown …  I’ve learned that sitting in your room can and will negatively affect your social life.”

COMPLIMENTING THREE OTHERS IN ONE DAY

“Giving out these compliments to people I had never met brightened up their day, and made me feel good about myself.”

JOINING A CLUB OR ORGANIZATION

“I chose to join the (a campus organization). I was worried that I would not have enough time to study and do homework. I quickly realized that, if I spend less time each day on the internet and watching television, I can get my studying done and go to (the club meetings and activities).”

SHOW THREE FRIENDS THE POWER POSE

“My third activity was showing three of my friends the “Power pose” TED Talk online. They all thought it was actually a good concept and thought about giving it a try. A few days later two of them came back to me and told me that they each tried it before a test and they felt better about those tests.”

LET GO OF SELF-JUDGMENT

“The fourth exercise I chose was something I really never thought I would do, “Let go of your self-judgment for a day. And do something others would never think you would do. Feel good about yourself. If others think ill of you – they do not matter; they are no longer part of your personal universe.”

THANKING A LOVED ONE FOR THEIR SUPPORT

“I posted this picture to Facebook, tagged both of my parents in it, and told them how much I really appreciate them. I also texted them both and thanked them for some of the little things that they do for me that mean so much. Of course, I couldn’t name them all because the list is endless. The instant trigger of happiness I added to their lives was the most self-rewarding feeling in the world.”

SPEAKING UP IN CLASS

“I, too, suffer from being incredibly self-conscious; I’m shy, timid, anxious, and extremely worried about what others are thinking about me. As a result, I generally keep my mouth shut during class, nod, and think the whole time, ‘Please, don’t call on me.’ When a teacher asks me to talk or present something in front of the class, I dread it. A very good point was brought to my attention by Dr. Rhoades – this was to ‘rush toward my fear.’ If you’re afraid of something, why drag it out? Get it over with and be able to feel the achievement after the task is completed. That’s why I decided to ‘speak up in class – when you normally would not speak up.’ So, when it was asked of the class to present a success tip and explain how it impacted our life, I volunteered to present. Yes, I was nervous, embarrassed, and afraid the kids would think I was foolish, but I marched on. Dr. Rhoades also said, ‘No one knows you’re embarrassed besides yourself,’ so I marched on. After the task was completed, I felt good about myself. It helped me realize that no one determines my happiness besides myself, so why does it matter what anyone else thinks about me?”

UNPLUGGING THE T.V.

“I chose to unplug my television for a whole week. I found this to be a bit challenging considering my absolute favorite shows … From doing this activity though I realized I finished a lot more homework earlier during the week and didn’t have to worry about doing it later at night after practice or a game like I usually would. I found that unplugging my TV actually benefitted me in that I focused more and got assignments done early and didn’t have as much of a distraction. Furthermore, I learned that if I want to get things done and out of the way I’ll do them first so then I can possibly have some down time to relax and watch TV once in a while and I can be worry free!”

“It felt good to not be such a couch potato and accomplish some stuff that I normally would have been scrambling to get done.”

CHANGING FRIENDS (i.e., “DON’T LIE DOWN WITH DOGS”)

“The last activity that I performed would be analyzing and changing my group of friends. Even though I came to Alfred State not knowing a single soul, it seems that I still tend to become friends with the same kind of people as I did back home. Not that there is anything wrong with the people I have become friends with as of now, but I would like my college experience to not be remembered by all the people I met who cannot miss a party but by the people who helped me reach my goal and provided a positive influence on me.”

POSTING SUCCESS TIPS FOR OTHERS TO SEE

“After putting these quotes up people asked me why I was on a positive mood streak or posting success tips. Instead of tell people I had to do an activity for class, I said because I am changing my life around to be a more positive successful person in my life. To strive to be the best I can be. Doing this has made me happier day-by-day, and made me feel better about myself. It is something I will continue to do at least once a week.”

“I chose to post a success tip every day for five days on my Twitter. I enjoyed doing this activity because I knew that someone was reading it and it may or may not have impacted their life in some way. I always got a favorite or a re-tweet on the success tips I posted. This activity makes me want to continue to put something inspirational up more often. There is too much negativity on social media, and I’m going to change that by posting my success tips!”

JOINING A STUDY GROUP

“I joined a study group. I knew that this would be a test to see if I were now more socially comfortable. In one of my classes we were to have our first exam, and I wanted to make sure I passed. Usually I enjoy working alone, but I wanted to see what difference it would make for me to work with others. I was amazed at the amount of ideas and tips I was able to put forward to help everyone pass. About two weeks ago I would have never wanted to work with others.”

GREETING OTHER PEOPLE FOR AN ENTIRE DAY

“This activity scared me, for I felt embarrassed to say anything to these strangers. I didn’t want people to think I am the weird freshman on campus. After I had done this all day, I began to realize that it became easier to say ‘hello’ to the people I passed by. I also began to take notice that the people didn’t think I was some weirdo, and laugh at me. They all just looked happy that someone said something to them and smiled back at me. Seeing the people smile made me happy and put a smile on my face as well.”

“As corny as this was, it managed to keep me in a decent mood throughout the day into the evening. I’ve realized that if you walk around the halls with a frown on your face it will put you in an uncertain, negative mood. One smile that you send out to a peer can change their day for the better.”

REFLECTIONS ON THE ASSIGNMENT

“Thank you for reminding me that there is always more room to grow.”

“I have realized that to be successful in life that one must go through many uncomfortable moments.”

“After each exercise, it became clearer that the more insecure I felt about completing the task before hand, the more I was able to learn from it.”

“It was evident that after reviewing all of the exercises that the ones that helped me the most were the ones that I feared the most.”

“Doing these six tasks was the most stressful and anxiety-driven experience of my life. They have also opened up a new door for me to explore myself … I hope to continue the process of expanding my comfort zone so that employers are willing to give me a chance to show what I can really do.”


“Thank you for teaching me to take risks.”

Ready to accept the challenge? Here is your assignment.

EXPAND YOUR COMFORT ZONE
Eleanor Roosevelt once wrote, “Do one thing each day that scares you.”
I once met two brothers, students in my class, who – despite having characteristics of introverts – were outgoing, friendly, and always willing to tackle new challenges. Having lunch with them one day, I discovered their secret. Each and every morning, as their mother sent them off to school, their mother said: “Do one thing today that scares you.”
We must realize that our brains are hard-wired, from the days of the cave men, to flee from danger. But in today’s society, where interpersonal skills are so highly valued, we need to learn to overcome fear. Otherwise fear prevents us from achieving, and it takes a far greater bite out of our life than we should permit it to do.
While not all fears should be overcome, many fears cause us to be anxious in social situations. To overcome these and related fears, each of us needs to seek to “expand our comfort zone.”
As you expand your comfort zone, you actually grow as a person to fill out these new boundaries.
If you have a larger comfort zone, and continue to push the edges of it out, you really do grow as an individual – you have more experiences, undertake more learning, and acquire more wisdom.
Understand the Need to Say “Yes”!
In the 2008 movie “Yes Man,” Jim Carrey plays Carl, who reluctantly promises to stop being a "No Man" and vows to answer "Yes!" to every opportunity, request or invitation that presents itself thereafter. While the result (in the movie) is both hilarious and, at times, moving, the movie is actually based upon a real experiment. In fact, after the movie, some individuals chose to say “Yes!” for an entire week. Here’s one blog post indicating the results: http://vladdolezal.com/blog/2009/my-real-world-yes-man-experiment/
If saying “Yes!” to everything for a week is too much of a challenge, then consider an alternative – calculated activities to expand your “comfort zone.” For much of the past 30 years, I’ve taken on the challenge of expanding my comfort zone. Being a severe introvert, I first learned how to socialize at receptions and similar events (a skill I am still working on). I began to give speeches and presentations, first to small groups; this evolved into my current ability to give speeches to a several hundred or a few thousand people at various conferences without any undue nervousness.
Each and every one of us has her or his own “comfort zone.” Studies have shown that 40% of college students possess social anxiety – i.e., shyness. And the remaining 60% possess anxiety in other circumstances, such as public speaking, meeting someone new for the first time, etc. The truth is that each and every one of us can expand their comfort zone, significantly, over time. And college is a great place to undertake this effort.
Why do this? Life’s magic occurs largely outside your current comfort zone. If you want to suck all the marrow out of life, as I do, you need to be willing to put yourself out there into areas of “discomfort.” Then, as you adjust, you become more and more comfortable in those situations, thereby expanding your comfort zone, you actually grow as a person to fill out these new boundaries.
If you develop a larger comfort zone, and continue to push the edges of it out, you really do grow as an individual – you have more experiences, undertake more learning, and acquire more wisdom.
In short, you experience life more fully.
As an added bonus, when you interview for a job in your career field you will be a better interviewee, and job candidate. The better jobs go to the graduates who are more personable and well-rounded!
Your Assignment: 
First, watch the following TedX talk, only six minutes long: “Measuring Comfort Zones” by Marcus Taylor at TEDxMelbourne. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jRE-x1zgsZU (6 minutes).
Then, for each of the next nine weeks, choose two activities each week from the list below. Choose those activities that scare you – i.e., those activities that expand your comfort zone. Please note that you may not repeat any activity.
At the end of each week, you should write down your progress in your journal. Schedule a reminder on your smart phone for the same day and time, once a week for nine weeks, to record your journal entries.
Your journal entries might start off in the following manner:
I expanded my comfort zone over the past week by undertaking two activities I would not have normally undertaken.
For the first activity I … (Describe the activity. What was the result for you? How did it make you feel?) As a result of all of this experience, I have realized that ….
For the second activity I … (Describe the activity. What was the result for you? How did it make you feel?) As a result of all of this experience, I have realized that ….
Here are the activities to choose from:
  1. Eat something different – a food item you have not tried in at least a year.
  2. Give at least three people compliments on any day, when you normally would not (counts as one activity).
  3.  Smile at (all) strangers, and say “Good morning” or “Good afternoon” or “Hi” to all the people you pass by, for one entire day – and wherever you are!
  4. Get to sleep (bed) one hour earlier for four nights straight, and at the same time each night (this counts as one activity).
  5. Speak up in a class – when you normally would not speak up.
  6.  Go to an on-campus event or which you typically would not go to, or engage in a new activity on-campus.
  7. Thank a friend or family member for their ongoing support.
  8. Tell someone they are loved.
  9. Let go of your self-judgment for a day. And do something others would never think you would do. Feel good about yourself. If others think ill of you – they do not matter; they are no longer part of your personal universe.
  10. Perform on Karaoke night.
  11. Show three friends or acquaintances the benefits of the “Power Pose” and show them the video (Google search: “TedX Power Pose”).
  12. Unplug your t.v. and video games for one entire week.
  13.  Use the writing center on-campus for assistance in reviewing the draft of an essay or paper.
  14.  Do your math homework in the math lab, seeking assistance when needed.
  15. Ask for a tutor.
  16. Form a study group, or join one, during the next seven days.
  17. See a professor for guidance on “how to do better” in a particular class, or on a particular assignment.
  18. See a professor for tips or career paths and/or “how to best network to find jobs or internships.”
  19. Obtain counseling at the student health center to talk through a problem or to seek ideas on how to relieve stress.
  20. Apologize to someone you have done wrong / admit you were wrong.
  21. Write a “personal log entry” in which you forgive someone for a wrong done to you. Let go of bitterness and anger. Let go of a grudge. (Whether you choose to communicate your forgiveness to the other person is up to you, and dependent upon the circumstances.)
  22. Perform three “random acts of kindness” in one day (counts as one activity). For ideas on random acts of kindness you might undertake, Google search the term “random acts of kindness.”
  23. Go up to a stranger in a student dining or coffee shop area. Introduce yourself and ask him or her if you can ask them a few questions, for an assignment you are working on. Find out the person’s name, major or occupation, hometown, and what they like most and least about the college or the program they are in.
  24. Change your group of friends (i.e., don’t “lie down with dogs”), or disassociate yourself over time from one friend who tends to drag you down.
  25. Undertake a civic engagement activity with others.
  26. Post a “success tip” once a day, each day, or your dorm room door or another place on campus, or on your social media page, for five straight days. Make certain you indicate below the success tip your identity, such as: “This success tip provided courtesy of (your name).”

These exercises can be powerful, if you approach them with an open mind and a view toward personal growth.
Take the challenge. Do six of the exercises above, and record the results.
Adopt the mantra of continual self-improvement, in all aspects of life.


Sunday, September 14, 2014

"I Choose to Excel" (A Message to Alfred State's Business Major Scholars)

For our Business Major Scholars …

I could walk around campus with earphones in, never smiling and never greeting any others. Or I could put a smile on my face, greet most who pass me by with a “Good morning” or “Good afternoon” or “How are you doing,” or – simply - “Hello.” I choose to excel.

I could not read the assigned material before each class, hoping that I will skate by just by listening to the professor and cramming before exams. Or I could read the text, answer sample questions, be prepared to participate in class discussions, and do well on all quizzes and exams. I choose to excel.

I could wait until the last possible moment to begin working on assignments. Or I could try to complete each assignment well in advance of the due date, even shortly after it is assigned, knowing that my ever-increasing self-discipline and self-control will serve me well in the real world. I choose to excel.

I could stay up late most nights, get a few hours of sleep, and arrive at class drowsy. Or I could get my 9 hours 15 minutes sleep (more or less, depending on individual needs), go to my classes and activities refreshed, and be more productive throughout the day. I choose to excel.

I could saunter about campus slowly, shuffling my feet, and generally try to look “cool.” Or I could walk tall, with good posture, at a good pace, and look to others as if I have a purpose. I choose to excel.

I could hold a grudge, and possess anger toward someone who did me wrong. Or I could write a letter to them exonerating them for their past actions toward me (regardless of whether or not the letter is delivered), free myself from any antagonism or resentment, and forgive and forget. I choose to excel.

I could write my required essays completely on my own. Or I could have a friend read my essay, travel to the Writing Center to have my essay reviewed and learn new tips on writing, and submit an even better essay with the likelihood of receiving a better grade. I choose to excel.

I could hang out with “friends” who study far too less and party, play video games, or watch t.v. far too much. Or I could realize that it is inevitable that if I hang out with those who choose not to excel, I will become like them. I could look for new friends, knowing that I am likely to become as successful (both in terms of personal relationships, and in terms of salary and wealth) as the average of my five closest friends. I choose to excel.

I could use my introversion as an excuse, by never asking questions in class nor engaging in class participation, hiding in the corner at the few parties I am dragged to attend, not joining any clubs or organizations, and not attending any on-campus events. Or I could realize that my introversion is a strength, as it permits me to perceive the world in a contemplative, reflective manner. And I could realize that I cannot use my introversion as an excuse – ever. I could also realize that most students, at some time, are scared of the challenge posed by the second greatest fear in life – meeting someone new. Hence, I could choose to gradually, incrementally push myself out of my comfort zone by doing one thing each day that scares me. I could choose to say “Yes” instead of “No” when asked to join in an activity. In so doing I will choose to make my life far richer and far more meaningful. I could choose to sit down with a student who is eating alone in the dining hall, asking the other student questions about their major, their life, and what they like about the college. In so doing, I could choose to possibly expand upon my number of friends. I choose to excel.

I could choose to abide by others’ expectations and judgments of me, living my life wondering if I am doing what is “acceptable” or “safe.” I could choose to always worry about how I look, how I talk, whether my make-up is well-applied, or whether I am always correct when I speak up in class or in a social situation. Or, I could realize that no one can put me down if I don’t let them. I could ask questions of my professors when I don't know the answer. I could live my life without fear of what others might say about me, enjoy each day in the manner I choose, and ignore put-downs by those whose worlds are so small that they must seek to often criticize others. I choose to live my life large. I choose to excel.

I could wait until my final semester to begin search for a job. Or, beginning in my second semester at college. I could make a list of all my contacts (including those who might be able to introduce me to employers in my field), attend the Alfred State Career Fairs each semester, undertake practice interviews, update and revise my résumé each semester, join and participate in clubs and organizations to enhance my attractiveness to employers, attend industry organization conferences and luncheons to network, and reach out to potential employers to “interview” them about their story, their successes and challenges, and seeking out career paths. I choose to excel.

I could blame others – my professors, my parents, my need to work to support myself, and/or my circumstances – for performing poorly in my classes. Or I could realize that I am responsible for my own success – no one else – and I could take charge of my own life. I choose to excel.

I could choose to go through life in a haphazard fashion, with big goals which always seem distant. Or I could choose to adopt S.M.A.R.T. goals every semester (or every few months), refer to them often, and undertake those actions which lead me toward their accomplishment. I could choose to live my life by design, not by default. I choose to excel.

I could choose to never be mindful of the world around me, forging through life always wondering why this did not occur or that did not happen, with little appreciation for the earth, its beauty, and the joys other people bring to my life. Or I could choose to treasure each and every day, expressing gratitude for little things such as the breath I take, a cool breeze, and a sunbeam on my face. I could choose to be thankful for the larger things such as the love of my family and friends; I could choose to let them know – simply by telling them that I love them and I appreciate them and all they do for me. I choose to excel.


Here are my 12 Key Tips for Success in College
Adopt a mindset of continual self-improvement and personal growth.
Obtain 9 hours 15 minutes (on average) of sleep to become more productive and to increase your capacity to learn.
When obstacles are presented, use your grit to persevere. Accept personal responsibility for your own success.
Possess S.M.A.R.T. goals – and review them daily.
Don’t let others’ views – or your own limiting views – define your own future.
Don’t lie down with dogs. Choose friends who also desire to be successful, and who work hard to be such!
Ooze confidence! (If you lack confidence, fake it until you become it! It works!)
Epand your “comfort zone” – do one thing each day that scares you!
Choose to want to succeed as much as you want to breathe.
Live one day at a time. Be thankful that each day brings forth a new opportunity.
Express gratitude to others, always.
Practice kindness, compassion, and empathy.

Challenge yourself to become a better person – and student – each and every day.
Thank you!
Professor Ron Rhoades
If you are feeling overly anxious, perplexed, and don’t know where else to turn, “SEE ‘DA BEAR.” I’m in Room 301 (in the inner office, past the copier), E.J. Brown Hall. If you desire an appointment, please e-mail me at RhoadeRA@AlfredState.edu.
  
Thank you.
Professor Rhoades


Ron A. Rhoades, JD, CFP®
Asst. Professor, Business Department
Curriculum Coordinator, Financial Planning Program
Alfred State (SUNY)
10 Upper College Drive
Room 301, E.J. Brown Hall
Alfred, NY 14802
Phone: 607-587-3469

Discover the transformational power of small class sizes, caring faculty who know you and call you by your first name, and a college dedicated to enabling you to succeed in all aspects of life.

We are a diverse, caring community of scholars, committed to succeed. We Are … Alfred State! Where ... It Matters!

For more information about Prof. Rhoades, please visit: